UM ... HI. I LOVE everything about this thread *hits the invisible like button*

I'm pretty sure my dog would be a slytherin as well... she's kind of sly/sneaky. But she's also like suppperrrr loyal to her family. Which reads slytherin in the very specific loyalty that she exhibits.

ON THE OTHER HAND.... she might have a touch of Hufflepuff cause she's quite food motivated, but I think it's when it benefits her, which is why I still standby Slytherin

pretty sure Hermione might be Slytherin too. Or Slytherclaw like her mama (me lol), but considering her quirk of being lovable to me and my mom but hissing at nearly everyone else...

My Waffles would have been a Slytherin, despite his intense trait of being loyal. He was always scheming on how to get me to feed him, for example - this included sitting next to his food bowl and giving loud meows and looking forlorn It was quite hilarious.

My dog would definitely have been a Gryffindor--outgoing, full of energy, eager to protect us, and always sure he could challenge any other dog, regardless of whether or not it was way bigger than he was. My cat, on the other hand--definitely Slytherin--cool, elegant, clever (he kind of looks like a Malfoy, if Malfoys were cats)--we used to live in a house with other cats and I would catch him tricking some of the other cats out of their food when no one was watching.

I forever love thinking about this question, but I still feel like I can never come to a conclusion for my kitty lol he's probably somewhere between Gryffindor and Ravenclaw. This animal taught himself to jump up different ways to use the door knob so he could let himself outside to go potty (litterbox is unacceptable to him) which suggests creativity akin to Ravenclaw to me. But then the rest of his personality is very Gryffindor-esque.

He's definitely not the cunning of a Slytherin or the friendliness of a Hufflepuff

This is such a great question! I have a lot of pets so bare with me

First I have my three dogs, Bailey is a mixed breed and Belle and Beau are Shih Tzu’s.
Bailey: He’s a Slytherin. He’s the sort of dog that will start trouble but then tell on the other animals when they join in. He’s all bark and absolutely no bite too
Beau: Let’s just say she is definitely NOT a Ravenclaw. She gives major Hufflepuff vibes as she’s so cuddly and loyal.
Belle: This one is difficult because she has two completely different personalities. She was rescued from a terrible situation and so is particularly frightened of strangers but at home she blatantly gets into mischief without a second thought giving Gryffindor vibes. It’s like she doesn’t even try to hide that she’s being naughty.

Now for the cats
Leo: I think this one is pretty obvious, he’s a Gryffindor. He’s brave, he has a very loud meow and he’s ginger.
Lionel: Ironically he’s not a Gryffindor like his name would suggest but more of a Ravenclaw. He’s extremely clever when it comes to breaking into things, opening doors and using his adorable face to manipulate his owners.
Samson: Gryffindor. He might be the smallest but he’s certainly the bravest. He loves to intimidate visiting dogs by pouncing on their tails.
Sadie: Total Hufflepuff. She’s the most relaxed cat you’ve ever met. She’s extremely people orientated and will never leave your side.
Saffron: She’s beautiful, she’s elegant and she will stare at you from across the room until you give her what she wants. Slytherin!

Finally the Lovebird Lyra who should be a Ravenclaw but she often hangs upside down in her aviary swinging her head from side to side and talking to herself in the mirror which doesn’t scream Claw type behaviour to me. She’s LOUD though. Gryffindor/Hufflepuff hatstall.

So, this doggo isn't my pet but he's a stray that lives in my area. I'm very attached to him since he comes to my house every morning and afternoon for me to feed him. He's FULL of energy! Because of this, I call him 'Frisky Boi' xD He's always fussing to put his front paws on the highest point of me that he can reach, he does the same jumping thing to my car's front window when he sees me about to pull into my yard after work and his tail is FOREVER wagging with such a force that I cannot help but wonder if it ever gets tired

I'd say Frisky's a Ravenclaw: he's very intelligent since he knows exactly when I'll leave for work in the mornings and he's always here on time for food, he always makes sure to stay out of drivers' ways {that is, he'll see a vehicle approaching and instantly get into the corner} and he reacts to basic pointing and gesturing {like when I point to indicate he needs to exit the yard so the gate can be locked}.

Ohhh my, my dog Vandal would definitely be a Gryffindor since she has no sense of self preservation in the slightest, and barks at anything that moves