| EmmaRiddle | 08-02-2009 04:39 PM | Quote:
Originally Posted by Looneybird
(Post 8459372)
I agree with what ppl on here are saying about the burrow burning down ...it was interesting for the film BUT
they should just have stuck w/ JK's material cuz they really messed up on a lot of the parts in the film. If they penetrated the burrow already then why couldnt they just kill Harry or take him hostage or something. There were so many things the death eaters could have done. There were member of the Order of the Phoenix there for god's sake! Kill them all is what they should have done! Plus where the hell was Ron in all of this if he was in the house wouldnt they have to run in and get him!!!! He was still inside and they were all standing there watching it burn!
It didnt have the "magic" that the previous movies had, excluding OOTP (which's the worst HP film yet). The burrow is a very homely place and they shouldnt have gone that far as to burn it...im just glad they're holding the wedding there.
In addition, isnt the burrow penetrated in the 7th book???!!!! That's when it matters. Anyways the following scene had no connection to any other scenes afterwards. It burned and they went back to school and lived happily ever after???!!! They put in an extra scene when they could have put in a KEY scene they forgot!!! What happened to the diadem when Harry hides the book? They couldnt jst have Harry hide the book and touch the diadem!!!! How are they gonna find it if Ginny is the one who hide it! Harry had NO idea where the freaking Diadem is. That wouldnt be hard! WOW i really went off topic there! lol. | That argument can be made for the books too - why not try and kill Harry earlier than May/June, every year? It's because we know the narrative would be dead as well, otherwise. Those are points at which you're asked to suspend your disbelief, yes even in the novels.
You just said it yourself; Ginny. If that means she doesn't hide in the RoR for the entire battle, like she does in the book, I'll be happy. Quote:
Originally Posted by darkone15216
(Post 8460902)
I cant wait to see who they picked to play Xeno Lovegood. Should be good. | That would be Rhys Ifans. Quote:
how are they gonna explain that, is Greyback gonna be one of the ones who attacks?
| Ron: My brother Bill, he got attacked by Fenrir before you got here, Harry.
Easy. :lol:. Quote:
It seems that alot of wizarding couples get married young,nothing strange in that.
| What is strange, is everyone marrying their high school sweethearts. But, you know, some of them could have got divorced *cough* Harry and Ginny *cough*. Quote:
I think we'll have to agree to disagree though, this scene is quite polarizing!
| I see your point, too. I like that the scene is there, and I see its intention but, like you, I think it could've been executed a bit better. But, at the same time, I can sympathise with Kloves, because in a magical world, it is difficult to come up with something that cannot be undone by waving a wand, or administering a potion, etc... |