Aww that's too bad. I was kind of looking forward to seeing a sloshed Trelawney

FIRST TO POST!!!

Aww maaan! Looks like they're going to change yet another thing from the book Meh. I get that they won't have time to show it all but at least keep the important stuff in! *pokes them*

HOW DARE THEY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
3rd to post!!!

Bleh.

Quote:

Meh. I get that they won't have time to show it all but at least keep the important stuff in! *pokes them*

I second that. I can't believe that Trelawney is not on HBP.

I can't believe she's not in HBP

Changing yet another canon fact from the book. For Merlin's sake. By the time they're done making all their changes, it'll be a completely different story from the original HBP!

Growl...I agree...with everyone.

I can't believe it! So are they going to make Harry figure it out himself? Maybe they'll make him walk past the Room of Requirement and hear Draco, and then maybe Dumbledore or McGonagall will let slip that Snape overheard the prophecy.

I'm gonna miss her.

I love the bluntness of the statement.



Tis a shame, realleh. Will anything of importance be left in, or will the travesty come true that HBP will in fact be a "romantic comedy" as someone put it at some point... I can't remember who.. either Emma or the director man. *ponders*

Aww. Not another character gone. *pouts*

That stinks! I wanted to see Trelawney with the cooking sherry! lol. Not to mention the fact that she's a great character....

First Dumbledore's funeral, now Sibyll Trelawney!? Are they putting anything into the film? But you know, I will not complain just yet, because it might be nice without Trelawney in this film. (No offense, but I don't like Emma Thompson's portrayal of S.T. :[ She just didn't seem like ... real when she was crying during the sacking scene. ((OOTP)) ) But I really liked how Harry found out that Snape told Voldemort about the prophecy. That was cool..... but whatever. I guess we won't have that? :[

ZOMG Dumbledore's funeral isn't in the movie either? Oh they are on their way to butchering this one

Great. Just great. They never give the best actors anything. They give the worst actors the most. (well, Emma watson and rubert grint are good, but...)

I was looking foward to seeing her.
And I was looking foward to seeing Mcgonagall's scene where she's stuned in the OotP.
Ah. what's the point of seeing the movies anymore? I bet you the next one to go will be snape and with them both gone the screen writer will have to completely change the plot and then it won't be harry potter anymore.

I think i'll stop ranting now.

That's very sad, but also understandable.

shes an important bit in the book and now they changed it!

Aw; that's sad. I was looking forward to seeing some of her scenes...she's not my favorite; but it would've been a bit more interesting with her in the movie. Oh; boy...this better turn out to be a good movie; considering how much they've already taken out of it. Oh well.

that is so much bull crap there changing everything trelawney is what makes harry potter,harry potter!!!!! ya know what i mean?

That was my main point... except i used more words...

Warner Brothers ... come on!

Aww, I was hoping she'd be in this one.

another change?
No Gaunts and now no Trelawny?
Seriously, she wasn't that big but when she was there SHE WAS IMPORTANT!

What are they doing? I mean, I understand not all can fit but it's like now the movie is turning into a as-long-as-Harry-and-his-friends-with-Dumbledore-are-there-it'll-hopefully-survive kind of Harry Potter movie! Seriously... with all these changes it makes you wonder what the movie will turn out to be.
Seriously, so far they're butchering like... the best book of the entire series (that's my opinion but it was pretty good generally and important for the series too)

I am now calling this movie "Harry Potter and the Half-Witted Script". Meh.