I can understand part of the uproar, but for people to come out NOW and complain about things not in the books being added to the films after so many unneccesary and unwarranted additions to th films (burning Burrow, anyone?) it's a bit too late. These stopped being "children's" books once Goblet of Fire came out, with the death of a fellow student. The audience has grown with the films. I see no problem whatsoever with the scene being mentioned. It FITS in the context of the book. It ENHANCES what is written in the book, it doesn't detract from it like a lot of other stupid additions have done. (Cheesy talking severed heads and Harry and Ginny's "Oops my lips might have hit yours for a fraction of a second", anyone?). And it's not being done for sensationalist purposes. I say bravo to the filmmakers, to JKR and to Daniel for going with it.