SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Weasley174 · 06-18-2012, 01:02 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kaos.Doodles

"Now, because Plato really did influence a lot of people and systems. Think about how possible is it that Atlantis existed. Remember, Plato was the only one to write anything about it. Could a man who had really lived his life based on education and facts really lie about something such as a city existing?" It wasn't his next question. He just let the idea sink in. "It just doesn't seem likely does it? What benefit would it be for him to lie?" None at all.

And so the conclusion was?

"Atlantis is still a real city." Point blank. It was no fable.

"Now many of you believed that the city itself sounded like a wizarding city. Why? Well, for one the rumour of it being underwater." Sounded like something wizards would do. "But if this is the case, was Plato a wizard?" And if they thought he was, WHY, and if they thought he wasn't, still WHY.

Knowing WHAT the man was, would determine, if the city had indeed been filled with Witches and Wizards, or Muggles.[/color]

OOC: Next post in around 15 hours (once again, give or take, depending on how many replies I get)

Laura looked at the Professor. "I don't care what the nurse say Professor, I think Plato is of great importance to us." Laura smiled at the Professor the nurse had no right to tell the Professor off for continuing the lesson after all this was a classroom and the silly healer should know that.

Laura smiled at the Professor and then decided to answer the Question. "Professor that's a hard question to answer because if Pluto was a wizard why didn't he know more and if he wasn't they he was a very clever muggle." Laura couldn't decided. "So on this partical question I am sat on the fence."

06-18-2012, 01:02 PM	#218 (permalink)
Weasley174 Giant Join Date: Dec 2007 Location: England Posts: 55,862 Hogwarts RPG Name: Mary-Lou Smith Gryffindor Second Year x8	The Idea Man Kori-Kins Quote: Originally Posted by Kaos.Doodles "Now, because Plato really did influence a lot of people and systems. Think about how possible is it that Atlantis existed. Remember, Plato was the only one to write anything about it. Could a man who had really lived his life based on education and facts really lie about something such as a city existing?" It wasn't his next question. He just let the idea sink in. "It just doesn't seem likely does it? What benefit would it be for him to lie?" None at all. And so the conclusion was? "Atlantis is still a real city." Point blank. It was no fable. "Now many of you believed that the city itself sounded like a wizarding city. Why? Well, for one the rumour of it being underwater." Sounded like something wizards would do. "But if this is the case, was Plato a wizard?" And if they thought he was, WHY, and if they thought he wasn't, still WHY. Knowing WHAT the man was, would determine, if the city had indeed been filled with Witches and Wizards, or Muggles.[/color] OOC: Next post in around 15 hours (once again, give or take, depending on how many replies I get) Laura looked at the Professor. "I don't care what the nurse say Professor, I think Plato is of great importance to us." Laura smiled at the Professor the nurse had no right to tell the Professor off for continuing the lesson after all this was a classroom and the silly healer should know that. Laura smiled at the Professor and then decided to answer the Question. "Professor that's a hard question to answer because if Pluto was a wizard why didn't he know more and if he wasn't they he was a very clever muggle." Laura couldn't decided. "So on this partical question I am sat on the fence." __________________ It's time for a party.