Nigel hoped Anya was not hurt because it looked like the Professor was whispering stuff to the Nurse and pointing at Anya. Hopefully the Nurse will fix her, the other students, and professors who were frozen. But Nigel could not really do anything about freezing students and professors. So back to the class and Professor Scabior's question.

Hmm.... Plato was a wizard, well that would explain things if Atlantis was a wizarding city. Even if it was underwater, which would be soooo cool. But Nigel had no idea if he was or not. Nigel was still think about how a city could be underwater if not with merpeople. It would seem like every human would die down there. Nigel did not know, so he thought why not take a guess. He raised his hand and said

"Professor, maybe Plato was a wizard who just loved doing smart muggle things. Maybe he just want to start a rumor among muggles about Atlantis and it did not matter if it existed or not."