Quote:
Originally Posted by
SilverTiger 
Until she'd heard the topic shift to Patronuses in general, away from the debate about Tonks' Patronus specifically, and she'd looked up again and over to the girl who'd spoken to her in the first place. "I wonder if Voldemort even would have felt he needed a Patronus. I mean, didn't he manage to get the Dementors working on his side? And he didn't need one for messages either. So he might not have even bothered," she replied. At least she could get in her opinion now. "And regarding Harry Potter's Patronus, you're assuming he used the exact same memory every time, aren't you? I'd guess he probably did feel like he resonated with his father, but that doesn't mean the memory he used had anything to do with his parents. Whether or not he actually remembered them," she concluded, glancing at the little Hufflepuff who had spoken as well. That had been a good point, for how young the girl was.
Kurumi's brain was one giant melting pot of ideas, and that was a very dangerous thing because it always meant that she was over thinking things to the point where she often confused herself despite the logic being in there somewhere.
Okay, first things first. Voldemort. "
I was just asking in theory, not if he would have ever wanted to produce one," she said for clarification. Clearly, her mind was stuck on the notion of a memory, a happy one, being necessary for producing a Patronus. Without it, it was just about intent like every other spell. Sure, you needed it to combat with the negative energies being brought about by Dementors, but she couldn't help but feel like there was more to that. "
What makes one capable of producing as opposed to not being able to." Skill level aside.
She shook her head. "
Not exactly, but I can see your point. I think I was looking at it from a broader viewpoint, perhaps how happiness resonates within each of us and that is what manifests itself in animal form. Having a huge shock to your system would certainly change your personal view on happiness and redefine it, which would explain why some people's Patronus changes."
Over analyzing? Yes please.