View Single Post
Old 11-19-2010, 03:59 PM   #25 (permalink)
longlivetoni
Guest
 
Posts: n/a
Default

my main issue was Dobby. the movies have never done him justice, and he has always come across as an annoying Jar Jar Binks type character in the movies. i think a lot of it has to do with the voice acting, which i GUESS they can't avoid because they felt tied to the same guy who did it in Chamber of Secrets. i have always wished they could have just gotten Jim Dale to do it. also the writing wasn't fantastic for Dobby in this movie. he had that long speech about freedom or whatever while bellatrix and the malfoys were staring at him before they apparated. that would not have happened in the book, i don't think bellatrix would have passively listened to that dumb speech. and then after they apparated, he had ANOTHER speech about how pretty the beach was and how much he liked his friends that i didn't like either. there's something about the suddenness of his death in the book that was awesome to me, how he was only able to say the words "harry potter" before passing is much more effective i think.

i had a few more tiny problems with the movie, but that was the biggest one i think. i loved the acting (for once), and the other action and emotional scenes were great. best movie of the series.
  Reply With Quote