View Single Post
Old 12-06-2009, 08:05 AM   #46 (permalink)
Antwone Thomas
Ravenclaw
Moonlight Dueler
Billywig
 
Antwone Thomas's Avatar
 
Join Date: May 2007
Location: California
Posts: 3,193

Hogwarts RPG Name:
Hayden Lynette Thomas
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by #1_harry_potter_fan_22 View Post
I love that high-five between Hermione and Harry too! It's so cute!
I believe that high five took place between Emma and Dan. I think they were OOC at that point.

Oops johnlocke06 beat me to it.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kavitha View Post
So the Harry/Hermione dancing scene is not during the Wedding.. see, told you that Kloves will mess up!
I don't see how Kloves is messing it up by adding a dance scene.

I think the reason Half Blood Prince is my favorite Harry Potter movie is because it did not try to copy the book chapter-by-chapter, which is what the first two movies did and they tended to drag and get boring.

In Deathly Hallows there is a lot of traveling and pondering which will not translate to film very well. Books are very passive in the way we experience them but movies are very proactive. To have Harry and Hermione sit sulking about the coming doom would be quite boring to watch and as a screenwriter Kloves has added a scene which will add spice and a little joy, because Harry and Hermione still have each other. While we're on the subject of adding/altering scenes, did you notice in the behind-the-scenes footage how they were being chased in the forest by what seems to be Death Eaters? Now I'm sure some of those who prefer movies to be tied down to their source material, plot-point by plot-point, would say this never happened or is uncanon. As I've argued before about movies being very proactive and visual, a scene like this probably breaks up the monotony of the trio just trekking through the woods for months. That or it could be an extension of the Snatcher scene.

I'm not to sure about your arguments against Kloves and the way he treats Ron. I think I would agree that he makes him look like a jerk in the first few movies but that's kind of what Ron is because he is a guy of heart rather than of intellect or valor. Plus, when you're younger to tend to be mean to those you like. Also, what about the last scene in Philospher's Stone! That was a noble thing for Ron to do!

In the end JK Rowling, though she really has no power within the studio system, has signed off on Kloves and I've gotten used to him and the film medium. We have to remember that these movies are a separate medium from the novels and they are told in separate ways!

Oh and I also do agree that Kloves did a little bit of Harry/Hermoine shipping in the first four films (until he took a break from Potter in Phoenix).

WHen you say "canon" moments in film what do you mean by that exactly. I'm just wondering. When you say canon do you mean the way they happened in the book or the way the felt in the book?

Quote:
Originally Posted by Kavitha View Post
P.S: one more doubt.. since they stupidly burned down Burrow in the 6th film, where exactly is the Bill-Fleur wedding taking place? They rented Malfoy Manor for the evening I suppose
I think their intent was right but the outcome was a little "eh..." in that new scene.
__________________

Last edited by Antwone Thomas; 12-06-2009 at 08:28 AM.
Antwone Thomas is offline   Reply With Quote