SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Hermione_loves_Ron · 09-24-2009, 03:02 AM

Offensive or defensive? Oy vey. Issy had a flash back to the last History of Magic lesson, with everyone debating things that were not set in stone. Heh, no pun intended. Scrunching her nose, she debated this. Hmmm.

Then she raised her hand.

"I imagine, in duels, the use of the spell depends. Perhaps it can be both offensive and defensive? In defense one could use the spell to prevent someone from attacking you. Or... maybe, if you have the agility, even turn the spells effects to stone? Though... I'm not sure about that." Bristling on, she continued. "However, offensively, you could use the spell to turn things into stone, as suggested, as use that to hinder someone. In a way, though, it almost seems entirely defensive... because in one way or another you're defending yourself, but regardless, I digress. Thus, I believe it plausible as both? Directly it would be defensive, but in using it to turn something else to stone and to use that against someone..."

Babble babble babble.

09-24-2009, 03:02 AM	#209 (permalink)
Hermione_loves_Ron Hungarian Horntail Join Date: Jun 2003 Location: Saffron City Posts: 69,656 Hogwarts RPG Name: November {Noe} Franze First Year	Brain Twin \| MASTAH ASHURRII \| Reisdent PokeNerd \| Digifangirl Offensive or defensive? Oy vey. Issy had a flash back to the last History of Magic lesson, with everyone debating things that were not set in stone. Heh, no pun intended. Scrunching her nose, she debated this. Hmmm. Then she raised her hand. "I imagine, in duels, the use of the spell depends. Perhaps it can be both offensive and defensive? In defense one could use the spell to prevent someone from attacking you. Or... maybe, if you have the agility, even turn the spells effects to stone? Though... I'm not sure about that." Bristling on, she continued. "However, offensively, you could use the spell to turn things into stone, as suggested, as use that to hinder someone. In a way, though, it almost seems entirely defensive... because in one way or another you're defending yourself, but regardless, I digress. Thus, I believe it plausible as both? Directly it would be defensive, but in using it to turn something else to stone and to use that against someone..." Babble babble babble. __________________ 'Cause out of all the people I've known, the places I've been, the songs that I have sung, The wonders I've seen, now that the dreams are all coming true, who is the one that leads me on through? TUNE IN! POTTERWATCH && BOOKCLUB