SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - Harry Potter: Be With You

onar · 06-09-2009, 05:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by matsa

Okay people please don't hate me but...I think Harry is right, that in some level he deserves all that. I mean I know Bellatrix was evil but wrong thing done for the right reason is still the wrong thing....yeah, sure, she deserved to be killed but it wasn't Harry's call to be made. She was a killer but that doesn't justify what Harry did and revenge is definitely not an excuse....
I'm sorry, I love Harry in this story and what he has with Ginny is amazing but I still think that what he did was wrong, he had no right to punish the guilty. Sorry, but morality bites and he just gonna have to deal with it...Ginny too..
Maria

Wait, so you're saying that Harry deserves to go to prison? Come on, Maria!!!!! Don't be so cold-hearted!!!!! And anyway it's like Ron says in DH in love and war everything goes....they were on war, things that happen in war are forgiven!!!! And anyway it's not like he doesn't feel bad about it!!! Come on!!! I'm soooooo not with you on this one!!!
-Angie-

06-09-2009, 05:08 PM	#578 (permalink)
onar Imp Join Date: Apr 2007 Location: Greece Posts: 416 Hogwarts RPG Name: Angie Palimor First Year	Quote: Originally Posted by matsa Okay people please don't hate me but...I think Harry is right, that in some level he deserves all that. I mean I know Bellatrix was evil but wrong thing done for the right reason is still the wrong thing....yeah, sure, she deserved to be killed but it wasn't Harry's call to be made. She was a killer but that doesn't justify what Harry did and revenge is definitely not an excuse.... I'm sorry, I love Harry in this story and what he has with Ginny is amazing but I still think that what he did was wrong, he had no right to punish the guilty. Sorry, but morality bites and he just gonna have to deal with it...Ginny too.. Maria Wait, so you're saying that Harry deserves to go to prison? Come on, Maria!!!!! Don't be so cold-hearted!!!!! And anyway it's like Ron says in DH in love and war everything goes....they were on war, things that happen in war are forgiven!!!! And anyway it's not like he doesn't feel bad about it!!! Come on!!! I'm soooooo not with you on this one!!! -Angie- __________________ Apostollo