SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - Michael Goldenberg talks Order of the Phoenix

ladycplum · 10-29-2008, 10:09 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by finfin91

I'm not quite sure what Goldenberg was trying to say here. Is he saying that JK missed something? Actually, movie #5 was my least favorite of the movies. I'm not sure if Goldenberg got the book. He made up some scenes that weren't that good. If he stuck more with the book, it would have been much better. He made Cho the bad one when in fact, it was her friend Marietta. He also added a scene where all of the DAs got punished. Too bad they didn't include a scene about seeing Neville's parents at St. Mungo's. I could go on and on. Glad that he didn't come back to do the rest of the movies. Boy, glad I got that off my chess.

Well, off to NYC and I'll see Equus on Friday!!!!!

Not to mention Neville's role in the prophecy as well. Glad he didn't come back, but considering what's been left out of HBP, I've pulled the WELCOME mat right back out from under Kloves's feet.

10-29-2008, 10:09 PM	#12 (permalink)
ladycplum Puffskein Join Date: Nov 2005 Location: Wherever Snape is! Posts: 1,593	direct diva Quote: Originally Posted by finfin91 I'm not quite sure what Goldenberg was trying to say here. Is he saying that JK missed something? Actually, movie #5 was my least favorite of the movies. I'm not sure if Goldenberg got the book. He made up some scenes that weren't that good. If he stuck more with the book, it would have been much better. He made Cho the bad one when in fact, it was her friend Marietta. He also added a scene where all of the DAs got punished. Too bad they didn't include a scene about seeing Neville's parents at St. Mungo's. I could go on and on. Glad that he didn't come back to do the rest of the movies. Boy, glad I got that off my chess. Well, off to NYC and I'll see Equus on Friday!!!!! Not to mention Neville's role in the prophecy as well. Glad he didn't come back, but considering what's been left out of HBP, I've pulled the WELCOME mat right back out from under Kloves's feet. __________________ Now THESE are vampires!