Fortunately Shay hadn't eaten all of her apples because the professor wanted opinions on which was which. Swallowing her most recent bite, she checked her notes and prepared to give her conclusions. Shay raised her hand and when called on, she made her case.

Holding the remnants of her apples up, Shay began to speak."I think this first apple is the one made by magic. There is no flat clump of candy coating on the bottom of this one. It doesn't look like it was dipped in the red coating and allowed to dry, like the other one. It's a little to perfect on the bottom. And this one doesn't exactly smell right. I can't explain it. It just doesn't smell jelly apple-ish enough.......oh and the color is a little too light." Shay was pretty sure about her choice. Now she just had to wait and see if she was right.