Minerva sat and listened to the others answering the question. She tried to figure out what could be in the potion. Hmmm it's not deadly, but it does make someone sick or pass out. Maybe old socks.. Minerva laughed in her head at her own joke, but then really tried to figure out what might be in the potion. She went to raise her hand to see if maybe the flesh eating plant from last term could be thrown into this potion just to watch it sizzle, but Professor Lafay put up the ingredients.

Taking out her parchment Minerva began to write. She looked and double checked her parchment to make sure she had all the ingredients put down. Dung?? Really?? Still better then blood and leeches that they had last term.