Originally Posted by EW_FAN

Harvey knew he had gone too far when she slapped him and screamed at him with all that she had been through.. this Minnie hurt him more than anything he had been through before.. he hung his head.. he knew he had gone too far.. she was right he didnt know what all that felt like.. he looked her he was defeated she WAS stronger than him... he was wrong.. he sat down in a chair.. defeated "You are right.. I dont know what all that feels like.. you have defeated me Minerva Wheatborn.. you have defeated me.. I am sorry.. I shouldnt have said that to you.. I am sorry.." he said not looking at her... he couldnt not after what he had just said.. how could he.. he was ashamed he had just made his girlfriend slap him .. he had NEVER dreamed that it would happen.. but here it had happened.. slowly he touched the cheek that she had slapped it still felt tender .. he still didnt look up...

Originally Posted by Rupert-Grint-Fan

This was really getting out of hand. "Ronnie let's change the subject. Let's get back to the party." Just then Harvey started telling her she changed and she was different. Tears started coming she couldn't stop them. She got up and slapped him. "How dare you Harvey Watson, How dare you. You didn't live in the locked room for weeks scared of what they are going to do next. You didn't have to live with being watched so you couldn't leave. You didn't have to hide away, change your hair." She grabbed her blonde hair to show proof. "You didn't have to hide wondering when they would find you and put you back in that room. You don't have to live with nightmares every night that when you wake up you are not waking up to your friends you are waking up to them. You don't have nightmares of them taking your friends and family and doing the same things to them they did to you." She was furious with him and getting louder and louder. "How dare you.... Have I changed, YES.. I am terrified that I will be forced away from my life again or worse my family or even you will be taken because of me."



Victoria listened as Kyle talked about Edward. "Well I know my girl is safe with you, but if she wants to go then I will let her." Just them the kids were getting louder. She looked at Kyle and Vinnie to see if they should interject. She never like to fight her daughters fights, but this was a serious matter that 12 year old children should not have to be dealing with. Her heart ached that her daughter had been through so much. Kyle then told Minerva she should go to Hogwarts. "Min I agree with Kyle you will be safer and have more fun with your friends. Honey, I have charms around your dad and Jacob they will never find them. The wizard is looking for yo the muggles are looking for the rest of us. I can handle them."

Minerva was so angry at Harvey that she didn't really hear her mother talking Without looking at her she said, mom I could help you with those charms, what if Edward starts coming after you. He will know the charms."