SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Whisper of the Heart · 07-21-2008, 10:29 AM

This was by far the best book of the series next to HBP. I was really sad that lots of people had to die for Harry to be able to defeat Voldemort, I cried when I read that Remus, Tonks, Hedwig, Fred and Dobby died.

Remus and Tonks had just started life as a married couple and had a child, then they were killed before they really got to know Teddy. Hedwig, what a way to kill off Harry's pet! It was just so sudden and unexpected! I wasn't expecting Fred to die, I always thought that if JK killed off one of the Weasleys it would be Percy. And Dobby, loyal to the end.

The fight at the end was brillient, but I thought the epilogue could have been a little longer, I knew that Harry and Ginny would get married and they would name at least one of their kids James and/or Lily, but Albus Severus? I always thought it would have been Sirius.

Overall, the book was great 10/10.

07-21-2008, 10:29 AM	#20 (permalink)
Whisper of the Heart Jarvey Join Date: Jul 2008 Location: With The Fairies... Posts: 619 Hogwarts RPG Name: Phoenix Elizabeth Talisman Third Year	This was by far the best book of the series next to HBP. I was really sad that lots of people had to die for Harry to be able to defeat Voldemort, I cried when I read that Remus, Tonks, Hedwig, Fred and Dobby died. Remus and Tonks had just started life as a married couple and had a child, then they were killed before they really got to know Teddy. Hedwig, what a way to kill off Harry's pet! It was just so sudden and unexpected! I wasn't expecting Fred to die, I always thought that if JK killed off one of the Weasleys it would be Percy. And Dobby, loyal to the end. The fight at the end was brillient, but I thought the epilogue could have been a little longer, I knew that Harry and Ginny would get married and they would name at least one of their kids James and/or Lily, but Albus Severus? I always thought it would have been Sirius. Overall, the book was great 10/10.