Time to weigh in on our first discussion. Post what your thoughts are, respond to another member's opinions, and have a good time. Just follow the site rules, and we'll all be fine. Remember... we're Aurors. Everyone's opinion is valuable, and no one KNOWS for sure. Be respectful.


Thanks to *harrypotterrulz* for our first topic. If you have an idea for the next topic, please post it here.

I think Tonks will have a much bigger role in DH than the other two she was in. I can easily see her helping Harry fight with Voldemort. She's a member of the Order and they're pretty much protecting Harry.
Will Tonks be with Remus? Or will one of them die? Hmm ... I hope the two get together. In my opinion, they're perfect for each other. But, Remus for some reason ... doesn't want to have a relationship with Tonks. I hope niether of them dies. I'd just be ... totally depressed if that happens.

I think a much bigger role too. some thinks she is evil...what is her true looks when she is not changing her hair or something?

OMG! I never thought of that. But if she was born Methamorphus (sp?) then I believe she doesn't have that random look. She can be whoever she wants.

^True but as she shows in the HPB sometimes her emotions tell her how she wants to look and she changes. I think Lupin just doesn't want her to get hurt...which is strange because she's an Auror and part of the order...although I think he doesn't want her to see him turn into a werewolf cause last time he almost hurt Harry and the gang and he's probably afraid now.

I agree that Lupin doesn't want to see Tonks be hurt. I'm not really sure why he just lets it be okay with him and Tonks being together. They're just perfect for each other! I don't think that Remus doesn't want Tonks to see him in his werwolf form. He knows that Tonks doesn't care, but he just ... I dunno. Just doesn't ... want to ... I don't know! He just wants to protect her for some reason.

Remus wont want her to gey hurt... & She doesnt care ...they are so perfect for each other!

^ true
^^ hmm maybe something happens to him when he turns wolf without the potion and he doesn't want her to know about it

She'd probably try to save him and end up dying herself. It's very fairytale but I wouldn't put it passed Tonks. I don't think Remus would either. Good point

as an auror she'll be in all the fighting scenes i just hope she's not one of the deaths...

^ True but Dumbledore had many more years behind him in training and Jo still killed him off (although with understandable measures) I'm not too sure as to when she'll come in apart from the fighting scenes and the wedding(!) but she'll have a sizeable part in protecting Harry

Mine too

I just hope she was the reprive !

it's almost more than likely that either Lupin or Tonks will die to save either Harry or each other...so I'm pretty sure there'll be some sort of emothional suffering

I don't want Tonks killed, coz she's just too cool, but I think JK might be evil and kill off either Tonks or Lupin. Coz splitting up one couple would keep the plot emotional and possibly more interesting! But I think she's more likely to kill Lupin coz he's older, then Harry would think
"There's only one marauder left, and I'm gonna kill him and his master *mwahaha*" shame though, I like Lupin 2 *sniff*

True she'll most probably kill him since he's the only one left apart from the weasley's that knew his parents. Plus he's the only one to have actually been best friends with James since Hogwarts

^hello there! I'm Lari

oh i hope it's the big happy ending! heheh. Remus needs some happiness, with TONKS and no one else.

hehehh....but alas Jo will have a different say in the ideal world you built!