Love in OotP

[Dainsie]

Ok guys, here's your new topic. I didn't know that the other one was shut till just now, so I appologise for the delay of getting the new one up. This is for ALL couple discussions so we dont have lots of topics, so start shipping :sorcerer: :flowersmile:

[DownWithTheDarkLord]

When was the other one shut down, AHH!!! so im starting the new one off!!!!!

Um quotes, quotes, erm (lost all of the other ones)

Well, lets see, Im gonna pretend this is my first time for this post

I ship :
H/G
R/Hr
N/L
Dumbledore/ Mcgonagall/Pomfrey
Snape/Dudley

LOL...

I have to go, ill wait for the queen and king of quotes (laura and lupin) to start posting some, because im lazy, we'll start from there.

Please dont put so many spaces in your posts, it makes them much to long and I have to go and edit them out, plus it looks funny...
Dainsie




Rob

[Shacklebolt]

Ground Rules

• Be Open Minded
  
• No bashing
  
• No swearing

• SS Board Rules Must be Followed
  
• Do NOT be self-centered
  
• And keep this a civilised debate.

I'm going to watch this thread closely, so be sure to follow the rules.

Thanks.

[Rovie]

Wait...wasn't another unpinned one started already? It was called Love in OotP2....

[Crazee]

Originally posted by rovie@Apr 14 2004, 03:11 PM
Wait...wasn't another unpinned one started already? It was called Love in OotP2....

Another was created, but not pinned! So which one is it then?

I won't reply till I'm sure! I don't want another one closed!

~ Felicia ~

EDIT: Did someone delete the other one? I was looking around and Love in OOTP 2 is gone!

[EmmaRiddle]

I think the other was closed.

Just to remind you, as if you all need reminding lol, I am a R/Hr and H/L shipper. I dont mind the ships H/G or N/L, I just would prefer them to not happen. I dont like the ships H/Hr H/D G/D or Snape/McGonagall.

I wouldn't mind Snape/Tonks, I think that'd be really interesting actually. But one does like to keep him for herself.

[Crazee]

Ohh if it's closed that means i have to repeat myself...Bleehh... :ermsmile:

Alright, i am a H/Hr.. but on ocassions i have a tendency to defend, H/L and R/Hr. And i remeber defending H/G once (ack, can't beleive i did it) ...

I like discussing any other ship - doesnt amtter which actually. And i cannot beelive we jsut lost over 60 pages worth of discussions... it's been over 5 months here!


And like DWTDL, i'll wait till Lupin shall start things of!


Oh question, because the pined Love in OOTP is officially gone - does that mean the our post count goes down? Or like we won't be able to find ANY ttrace of the topic what so ever? Not even in the "Find all posts by this member" thing?


~ Felicia ~

[Ginpotter]

I think that Hermione loves RON..Not HARRY.... and Ron also loves her..We don't know what will happen between Ginny and Dean???? I think they will break up..Cho won't be with harry again..Rowling said that.. So...I think we must wait and see....( I can't wait)

[EmmaRiddle]

I think with Cho/Harry, there will be obvious repercussions and she may even end up crying on him again, but romantically, it's over for them.

I dont think Ron knows exactly how he feels, JK said there's something going on between R/Hr, but Ron doesn't quite know it yet. I think Hermione does, but perhaps she's closed about it because she doesn't want to be rejected by someone like Ron who's her friend and who's been there through everything.

Luna liking Ron is definately and has already caused sparks to fly between Herm and Luna and Hermione definately became jealous of the fact that Luna liked Ron in OoP. Overall, Luna is the catalyst that they need to push them together. Luna has helped Hermione realise she's getting jealous over Ron.

[Crazee]

Originally posted by Ginpotter@Apr 14 2004, 06:33 PM
I think that Hermione loves RON..Not HARRY.... and Ron also loves her..We don't know what will happen between Ginny and Dean???? I think they will break up..Cho won't be with harry again..Rowling said that.. So...I think we must wait and see....( I can't wait)

Actually no where in the books does it SAY that Hermione LOVES Ron, or whether Ron LOVES Hemrione. We can only assume.

It's OBVIOUS that Ron likes Hermione, but i'm not 100% certain whether Hermione likes Ron back in the same terms, i'm currently on 90% certain that Hermy likes Ron...

And yes i am a H/hr, weird isn't it? Let me explain...

I know that H/Hr will not happen, but when I interpret the book myself, i can see it. I know JK is leading us to R/Hr and i'm fine with it - but through my eyes i think H/Hr is possible... yea go on laugh at me...


-Felicia

[EmmaRiddle]

H/Hr would've been possible, had JK not said so many shocking things against it and I can see where you guys get your evidence from. And it is there. But that's all inerpreted as Sisterly/Brotherly now because it's been dismissed, but all evidence could be called that if JK decided to say another couple were platonic, so there could've been romantic implications in the beginning. If that makes any sense whatsoever. lol

[Ginpotter]

In book three and five there are evidences that Hermione LOVES Ron .... Sorry I forgot and in book four also!!!!
Hermione is jealousy at Ron not at Harry...She said to Harry in book five that Cho was looking at him all the time and Hermione was similing!!!!!!! on the contary She was angry when Ron said about Fleur that She was Villa...and when he said to Fleur that her English is good at the end of book 4.... and was also angry when Ron didn't invite her to the Ball....
Of course every one has his own opinion... Every one free

[EmmaRiddle]

I think Hermione was jealous of Fleur without quite knowing it. If she had known it properly, then she wouldn't have been so shocked at the amount she became jealous when Luna started to show feelings toward Ron. I think post-OoP is when Hermione will finally realise how she feels and stop denying it.

[Lupin Jr]

Sorry, Dainsie accidently deleted the other topics, but that's okay so we can start a new.

I ship the following:
Harry/Ginny
Ron/Hermione
Neville/Luna
Draco/Pansy
I don't mind the following:
Harry/Luna
Hermione/Neville
Neville/Ginny
I disagree with the following:
Harry/Hermione
Ron/Luna

I think Hermione come some what better aware of her feelings near the end of GoF, but perfected them over the summer. I don't know how she feels now, but she doesn't seem to mind Ron's crush on her, so who knows what she is feeling?

Yeah I locked the new one before i realised the 1st one was closed. And once I lock them I cant unlock them, so I just had to start a new one. Ah well, get some extra posts dont you! And to answer someone's previous question, no I dont believe your posts go down when a topic is deleted. Once you've made them they count, so they shouldn't...
Dainsie

[EmmaRiddle]

I thnik she likes the attention, but doesn't like to feel threatened, as if that might be taken away by someone like Luna. Even though Luna stands no chance with Ron.

[loony lupin]

awww weely? i quite like ron/luna*makes sick/cute puppy face*
my reason is that ron as a pureblood is quite complacent in someways. he's become rigid and takes quite a bit for granted. and luna will be a wake up call for him. not in the way that hermoine is- u know always informing ron with an air of impatience or "oh dont be so stupid ron"
i want to ronniekins with a gal who wont belittle him. but at the same time wont simper up to him. luna will do him good.
and in some interview ages ago, jk was asked if harry and co would sneak into other common rooms again and she was all*teasingly* not telling
so it could be for luna. but that could be harry/luna or ron/luna
then again it could be pansy/harry
or the whole event could be something non romantic

but u know something else i found interesting? ive rarely ever come across a ron/luna shipper. apparently everyone's convinced that hermoine's the only one he fancies
whereas we have h/hr. d/hr. n/hr
as an ardent ron fan, i must be all flappy abt it shouldnt i? lol

[Crazee]

Originally posted by Emma+--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (Emma)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'>H/Hr would've been possible, had JK not said so many shocking things against it and I can see where you guys get your evidence from. And it is there. But that's all inerpreted as Sisterly/Brotherly now because it's been dismissed, but all evidence could be called that if JK decided to say another couple were platonic, so there could've been romantic implications in the beginning. If that makes any sense whatsoever. lol [/b]

Nope. it amde complete sence. ig et what you mean, don't worry!

Originally posted by Ginpotter+--></div><table border='0' align='center' width='95%' cellpadding='3' cellspacing='1'><tr><td>QUOTE (Ginpotter)</td></tr><tr><td id='QUOTE'>In book three and five there are evidences that Hermione LOVES Ron .... Sorry I forgot and in book four also!!!![/b]

NO! Don't confsue a CRUSH with 'LOVE'! We as readers cannot be 100% sure that these two LOVE each other, they are only 15! How do you know LOVE? We understand however, that they do have feelings towards each other, though these feelings have not yet been resolved.

Hermione is jealousy at Ron not at Harry...She said to Harry in book five that Cho was looking at him all the time and Hermione was similing!!!!!!!

(sorry to DWTDL, Laura, lupin who've read this before) Alright. The fact that she noticed that Cho was looking at harry can mean somehting. Hemrione noticed that Cho couldnt' 'keep her eyes of him' - doesn't that mean that Hermione herself was looking at the two for qutie some time?

on the contary She was angry when Ron said about Fleur that She was Villa...and when he said to Fleur that her English is good at the end of book 4.... and was also angry when Ron didn't invite her to the Ball....

i know. This CAN mean she was jealous - of course. but some other readers, no me personally, think there is TOO MUCH bickering in order for a relationship to work between Hr/R! See where i'm comming from???

<!--QuoteBegin-Lupin@
I think Hermione come some what better aware of her feelings near the end of GoF, but perfected them over the summer. I don't know how she feels now, but she doesn't seem to mind Ron's crush on her, so who knows what she is feeling? [/quote]

Hmm yea. This is rather true... She doesn't seem to get SOO flustered over ROn anymore... =S

<!--QuoteBegin-Emma
I thnik she likes the attention, but doesn't like to feel threatened, as if that might be taken away by someone like Luna. Even though Luna stands no chance with Ron. [/quote]

Yea it's not as if Hermione gets ALOT of attention, well from guys anyway... she mgiht like it. fair point this!

I have to go!

-Felicia

[EmmaRiddle]

i want to ronniekins with a gal who wont belittle him. but at the same time wont simper up to him. luna will do him good.

Even though I dont like R/L, I agree with you here.

apparently everyone's convinced that hermoine's the only one he fancies

Well, in OoP it's fair to say Ron doesn't like Luna at all really. But who knows, anything can happen in the next book. On a second read of this, woah am I turning R/L shipper? Well no but I can see your point.

no me personally, think there is TOO MUCH bickering in order for a relationship to work between Hr/R!

If you think about it, in the books, Molly and Arthur bicker alot too, especially in the LC in PoA, so in that sense, they mirror the Weasley adults.

doesn't that mean that Hermione herself was looking at the two for qutie some time?

I think she did this because as a girl, she knows more about Cho than Harry probably does and maybe knew what type of girl she was and that she wouldn't be good for him. That can be seen as love, but I see that as trying to look out for a friend by monitering her around him.

[Lupin Jr]

I think she did this because as a girl, she knows more about Cho than Harry probably does and maybe knew what type of girl she was and that she wouldn't be good for him. That can be seen as love, but I see that as trying to look out for a friend by monitering her around him.

Come now, we all know just how observent Hermione is, she notices every single detail, right down to Umbrige's subtext (and who honestly listens to teachers speeches?).

[EmmaRiddle]

Originally posted by Lupin Jr@Apr 14 2004, 12:18 PM

Come now, we all know just how observent Hermione is, she notices every single detail, right down to Umbrige's subtext (and who honestly listens to teachers speeches?).

In other words what I said goes without saying? Well you forget others are younger, so I had to say it to explain myself.

[Shacklebolt]

Originally posted by Marcella_Riddle@Apr 14 2004, 01:50 AM
I think the other was closed.

Just to remind you, as if you all need reminding lol, I am a R/Hr and H/L shipper. I dont mind the ships H/G or N/L, I just would prefer them to not happen. I dont like the ships H/Hr H/D G/D or Snape/McGonagall.

I wouldn't mind Snape/Tonks, I think that'd be really interesting actually. But one does like to keep him for herself.

I also follow H/L and R/Hr.

H/G is fine with me too.

S/T would be really interesting, I agree

[Crazee]

Originally posted by Emma
If you think about it, in the books, Molly and Arthur bicker alot too, especially in the LC in PoA, so in that sense, they mirror the Weasley adults.

Very true, go tell the anti R/Hr's that!

I think she did this because as a girl, she knows more about Cho than Harry probably does and maybe knew what type of girl she was and that she wouldn't be good for him. That can be seen as love, but I see that as trying to look out for a friend by monitering her around him.

Fair enough. Have you noticed, Hermione is always somewhat cheeky at the weirdest of times, JK uses her near cliffhangers often... :/ Not that that was relevant to what i quoted!

Come now, we all know just how observent Hermione is, she notices every single detail, right down to Umbrige's subtext (and who honestly listens to teachers speeches?).

Heheheh lol, true. But Hemrione is just it. She listens to everything, knowing that it will do her well - she never seizes to amaze me!

-Felicia

[HP_Gem54]

QUOTE (Emma)
If you think about it, in the books, Molly and Arthur bicker alot too, especially in the LC in PoA, so in that sense, they mirror the Weasley adults.

Very true, go tell the anti R/Hr's that!

I agree! I have heard that theory many a times before and if you read this quote from the book:

"What do you think about this?" Hermione demanded of Ron, and Harry was reminded irresistibly of Mrs. Weasley appealing to her husband during Harry's first dinner in Grimmauld Place.

Now that is definetley saying something.

Fair enough. Have you noticed, Hermione is always somewhat cheeky at the weirdest of times, JK uses her near cliffhangers often...&nbsp; Not that that was relevant to what i quoted!&nbsp;

Okay this is totally off topic but ummm.....what does Cheeky mean? I know really silly question but I am curious.

I also follow H/L and R/Hr.

Dido!