i noticed that too!!!!!! i was just like 'she didn't punch him like that!!!' and the way she is standing is not the same eather, she has her legs spreded far apart and is facing compleatly forward with her wand out, when she did it the first time she was facing side ways with her wand out. ::tisk tisk:: i think it's kinda sad when they don't notice this stuff and we do!!!

Has anyone noticed that they forgot to add the part that explains the marauders map. I was sooooooo annoyed that they didn't add it

i know...that waz so annoying!!!!

n-e-wayz...did anyone see that when Harry and Hermione go back in time, they run right by that dude in black again!!!!

and when Harry is under the Invisiblity Cloak, and he's in Hogsmede, by the Shrieking Shack, and freaking out Draco, Crabbe, and that other dude...he dosn't leave any foot prints!?!?!? but he dose when he's walking through Hogsmede, and in the forest when he's all upset about Sirius being James and Lily's Freind, and "selling the out"...????

Wow, I've never noticed those mistakes.
I have to look more closely to the details if I ever watch a movie again.

Yes, I did noticed the footprints and the part with that creepy guy in black.

I forgot all about that marauders part.... It was kinda odd, not explaining all the names. I wonderh how they're gonna fix that in the next movies...

Even if there were mistakes it was a great movie.

The part where Hagrid tells them that Buckbeak has been sentenced to death, Harry sits on a rock and then stands up, as the scene ends and you get the shot from above, Harry is suddenly sitting again.

Wow there were a lot off mistakes. I didn't see anything wrong but i will look for the ones you posted
It was a pretty good movie all together but why would you change the whole look of hogwarts? I thought that was soooo dumb i also thought it was stupid how they didn't explain the maruader's map

I noticed the headphones on the Tv.

When Lupin stops the dementor on the train, he stands up and says nothing, yet silver patronus comes out of his wand!

Also, on the train ride to Hogwarts, Ron puts his hand on the window which frosts, so when he takes it off there is a handprint. But in the next shot of the window, it is gone.

Oh ya, and (while i'm sure it wasn't a mistake) during the buckbeak class scene, right after Ron pushes Harry forward, there is a shot of Buckbeak pooping! But look carefully, it's easy to miss.

When i watched it i didnt notice any mistakes it was perfect!

The Big Mistake occurs when Harry produces the Potronus[sp?]:
when he sees it across the lake it is a stag, but when later in the movie he accually produses it there is no stag: his wand makes the same half-sphere light-thing he used to make in Lupin's office.
It is really silly because the whole piont was that it was the first time the made the real potronus and it saved so many lives.Besides if Harry stood there with all the light around him,like in the movie, harry-from-the-past(the one who was near sirius) would have had no difficulty whatsoever in recognizing himself.

_____________________________
But I think that in spite of the mistakes it is the best HP movie yet. It is really good, IMHO even perfect =)

way better than the others anyway.

That my oppinion.

wow, i never noticed, guess i'll just have to watch for it

PoA was a great movie. But, there were so many mistakes that I could see! Here's quite a few of the movie mistakes.

Must Not Be Seen... - When Dumbledore tells Harry and Hermione they "mustn't be seen," their Time-turning doubles rush past where MacNair is still sharpening the axe. Unless MacNair was looking the other way, this means they were seen by him twice!

Sleeping Beauty - After Harry passes out after he and Sirius are attacked by dementors, he wakes up at the hospital wing hours later as though barely a few seconds had passed to find out Sirus has been captured. During the scene where Harry and Hermione go back in time and you can see what had been going on in the hospital wing in the past three hours, you can see that Harry was awake ever since he was brought to the hospital, drinking medicine and getting up and opening his eyes several times before the time he talks to Hermione. Didn't Harry feel concerned about Sirius then?

Inner Eye? - In the scene where we first see Professor Trelawney, she mentions "casting ourselves into the future." Hermione isn't even in class yet, but later when they are walking down to Hagrid's hut, Hermione makes fun of Trelawney's words in a mocking voice even though she wasn't even in the class to hear Trelawney speak them!

Turn Turn Turn - In Buckbeak's execution scene when Harry, Ron, and Hermione are running up the hill from behind the pumpkins, Harry turns around and looks back at Buckbeak. When Harry and Hermione go back in time, Harry doesn't turn around but starts to run past Hermione.

A Bit Obvious... - In the scene where Harry lands and dismounts Buckbeak, Hermione starts talking with the camera facing her. If you notice, her black robe is off, but she still has the Time Turner on where everyone can see it. No one is supposed to see it at all. You can't see the hourglass itself, but you can see the gold chain in the shot, meaning that Hagrid and Harry can see the entire Time Turner when they're not supposed to.

Moving Book - When Harry goes to pick up the Monster Book of Monsters in his room at the Leaky Cauldron, there is a stack of books next to it on the bench. The small book on top shifts sideways as the camera angle changes.

Checking the Lense - When Mrs. Weasley hands Scabbers to Ron through the window of the train, Rupert looks into the camera as it moves parallel to the train.

Sensing the Future - As the Fat Lady sings, three girls are watching from the picture on the right. The girl in the pink dress starts flinching before the Fat Lady hits the bad note.

Undecided Book - When Ron pushes Harry towards Buckbeak during the Care of Magical Creatures lesson, both of Ron's hands are empty, but when the camera angle changes to a far away shot, he is holding his book. In the next few shots, he is still holding it, but it changes positions slightly. Then, when Hermione grabs his sleeve, the book disappears, comes back and then vanishes again when she grabs his hand.

Tie Size - In most of the scenes where Harry is wearing a tie, the thin part of it is considerably longer than the wide part, but when Harry flies on Buckbeak, both parts are the same length.

Frozen Sirius - When Seamus drops the newspaper with Sirius's picture on the table, the picture is barely visible but is obviously not moving. It doesn't start moving until the above view.

Not on the Same Subject - During Snape's Defense Against the Dark Arts lesson, all of the students' books were open to different places; some near the front, some almost to the end and some near the middle. The book at Snape's podium was open to close to the center, but when he turned Ron's book to the right page, it was much closer to the end of the book.

Moving Bruises - Harry gets cuts on his face during the Quidditch match, but later when he wakes up, the cuts are at different angles and in different positions on his face.

Crabbe's Scarf - In the scene outside the Shrieking Shack, the scarf around the Slytherin boy's neck is untied at first, but when Crabbe's pants get pulled down, it is suddenly tied in a knot and is standing away from his body as though it's stiff with wire (in preparation for being pulled straight outward). It is untied again when he climbs the hill with Draco and Goyle.

Make Some Room! - In the Three Broomsticks' back room, Harry shouldn't have to hold the Invisibility Cloak away from his face, since it is completely see-through. He held up the fabric to accommodate the camera.

Slowing Clock Bells - In the scenes with the clock bells, they ring when Harry and Hermione leave the hospital wing. But, they are much farther apart than they are any other time during the movie.

Don't look! - Daniel glances into the camera when he and Hermione (back in time) are peeking around the pumpkins to look at Fudge, Dumbledore, and MacNair entering Hagrid's hut.

Misplaced Willow - When Sirius walks toward Hogwarts and talks with Harry the first time, their backs are towards the Whomping Willow, but later, when Harry and Hermione are in the trees, the Whomping Willow is to their right, putting Hogwarts behind Lupin, in a completely different place.

Fast or Slow?- When Professor Lupin transforms into a werewolf, his transformation happens at normal speed. But when Harry and Hermione go back in time, Lupin's transformation happens a lot faster than the speed it occurred the first time.

Double Agent - In the Boggart scene, when the camera pans around the giant cobra, you can see a man both in the mirror and on the left of Parvati. But, once the camera comes around, it's someone who looks somewhat like David Thewlis but is not. He has his hair covering most of his face and is in a position that looks something like cowering to hide both his height and his facial features, but it is obviously a double. This double's hair is longer and a deep brown as opposed to Thewlis' shorter-haired light brown.

Where's That Coming From? - In the "spiders want me to tap-dance" scene, Harry is reading the Marauder's Map by wand light. The light is obviously not from his wand because when Harry says, "You tell those spiders," the shadow shows the wand clearly outlined. It's impossible for the wand to cast its own shadow!

Granger, Master of Disguise - When Hermione and Harry go back in time and Harry conjures the Patronus, Hermione is leaning against the tree directly behind Harry. In the scene where originally Harry is fighting the dementors and Sirius is unconscious, the camera cuts to the time-traveling Harry conjuring the Patronus several times. During these cuts, we should be able to see Hermione leaning against the tree behind Harry, but she's mysteriously not there.

Bad Hair Day - When Snape is substituting for Lupin in Defense Against the Dark Arts, Hermione's hair keeps changing. Sometimes it is completely down and others times it is half back.

The (Other) Magic Flute - When Harry is with the Weasleys in the Leaky Cauldron, there is a little boy playing some sort of woodwind instrument. We hear him play a long, sustained note, but his fingers are moving. If his fingers are moving over the key holes, we should be hearing multiple notes.

Self-Straightening Tablecloth - When Aunt Marge is inflating in the beginning, the tablecloth she grabs crumbles up when she drops it. Later as she flies out, they flash back to the table and the cloth is still there under the dinner things.

I just watched it and noticed a few more mistakes.

In the scene where the class meets buckbeak, they show a shot of Hermoine grabbing Ron's sleeve. In the next shot of Harry, you can see Ron and Hermoine in the background, and she is not holding his sleeve, but then quickly grabs it.

Also, in the dementor on the train scene, it shows the light in the trio's cabin going out. It then shows a shot of the outside of the train, where you can see Ron's hand up against one of the windows, and the cabin light is on the blinks off.

In Prisoner of Azkaban when Harry and Hermione travel back in time to Hagrid's hut the vase shatters in two different ways.

I don't know if the scar moving around thing has been corrected yet, but I saw this movie yesterday and if you pay attention, you'd be able to see that after the boggart was put back into the wardrobe, the camera zooms in on Harry, so the scar moving around thing was supposed to be his reflection

Now there are two movies that I am going to have to watch over again.

ive noticed only a few of these mistakes but next time i watch the movie i will most certainly look for them!

Exactl;y where did he get such nice cloths? and his scar is never in the same place. he never fought the boggart at all in the book. WHERE ARE THE GREEN EYES?????? ANYONE????I honestly this is my least favorite harry potter movie yet any one els?

I noticed in the begining where Harry is preforming underage magic, and he dosen't get caught, and that they're wearing Muggle clothes for like, the whole movie!

Yeah he does magic to get light to do his homework and never got in trouble for it.

Anyway, what about the part were he is under his invisibility cloak at the Shrieking Shack and he is messing with Malfoy and the cloak falls of his head and Malfoy runs back to the school and tells Professor Snapes what he saw.