This discussion was due to start last week but we've all been busy so I'm presenting it today.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Sean aka roonilwazlib

How about Harry searching for the horcruxes and the impact others will have that follow him. At the end of Book 6, Hermione and Ron said they were coming with him. We know at least they'll be helping Harry.

To get you started I'll give you two ideas we've already started discussing in our first HPFC thread:

• Will the trio search for the Horcruxes on their own or will other DA members join them?
• Are there really as many Horcruxes as we think?

Have fun - and remember to respect other people's opinions.

Yep! I think that the trio will go alone to destroy the horocruxs but may be at the end Ginny, Neville and Luna will join them but I don't think that ALL the DA will go with Harry.
I think that what DD said is true but may be some guesses be wrong like for example Nagini won't be a horcrux but I think the number of them is as DD said.

I also think the Trio will just go and do it for a bit, but if thinkgs getty sticky they might call on some of the DA, Ginny, Neville and Lunu most likley.

As for the number of Horcruxes:
I thik Dumblebore is right on what he said, why would he lead harry astray on something like that. I think that harry know what he has to go do and what ones are still their and not still thier.

The trio will go alone, maybe a few of the DA memmbers will join them, but i dont see harry leting anyone really go with him. So i mostly think its just going to be the trio and maybe one or two of the otheres.

Yes i think that Dummbledore did not make too many bad choices and that thier are that many, though some of them might allready be used, or elemindated.

The trio may search for the Horcruxes alone.Maybe Ginny,Neville and Luna may help.
Yes,I think there are that many horcruxes.i believe DD and what all he says. I think some are already destroyed.it was there in the HBP,in the letter of RAB that I will make you mortal when you meet your match.

I think harry will intionally plan on going with ron an ginny but neville will askand harry will let in because Voldermort is techniquelly his bussiness and he deserves his revenge.But ginny will ask and harry and ron will say no because they want to protect her, but hermione will stand up for her and convince them. There are probably as many horucruxes as dumbeldore says.

I think there are 7 horcruxes. And I also think that Harry will seach for them alone. I don't think he wants Ron and Hermione to go with him.

I'm hoping that Ginny, Ron and Hermione will force Harry into letting them go with him, he needs the love of his friends and Ginny the find and kill Voldemort and his horcruxes so... "We're on a horcrux hunt... horcrux hunt, we're on a horcrux hunt... horcrux hunt...."

I think Harry will let Ginny, Ron, and Hermione find the Horcruxes with him. But then, DD will tell him that Ginny is a horcrux and Harry realizes he has to kill her. But then, Ginny will jump in front of a spell meant for Harry killing herself so Harry doesn't have to kill her. Then they will find the rest of the Horcruxes and another will by Harry and Harry will have to kill himself. A bleak outlook eh?

blimey that's a depressing theory a probable one though, it's all down to whether JK decides HP is a tragedy or not...

Deathly Hallows has been released, the Horcrux Hunt is over. And now, let's discuss it!

Did you like that Harry himself was a Horcrux?
What about the fight the Trio had just before Ron left them?
Were you surprised that Harry actually managed to find all Horcruxes?

At first I didn't like the fact that Harry was a horcrux, until it said he wasn't actually dead, then I didn't mind! It did make sense after all...
When Ron and Hermione started turning against Harry and talking about him behind his back, I was furious! He'd never said he'd had a plan... *slaps them*

So, we already know the answer to this one, but I want to add that I don't think Harry could have done it without the help of Ron and Hermione. He needed them to finish the task. I think it was a wonderful growing experience for Harry to have to rely on his friends and let them help him.

^ Harry would never have been able to do all he did without the support of his friends and family too. But Ron and Hermione, in my opinion, preserved his goodness.

^Ron and Hermione did keep him on track. Harry was tempted so many times and they stood by his side and gently guided him back on track.

^ Yeah, they always were the reason he could survive, remember the dementor attacks? He always thought about them to produce his patronus.

They also found out a bunch of info for him along the way. It's actually kind of sad that his friends, mostly Ron and Hermione, didn't get more credit for the way things turned out. I think Harry knew that he couldn't have survived without them...like why he thought about them when times got bad.

Yeah, can you think what Harry would have done without them? Especially Ron?