YeEeEeCH people u r confusing me. but sirius is... no but seriously... oh i dunno!!

but well i was (don't laugh) trying to write my first fan fic... and the chapter of book 6 supposedly. don't worry im not posting it nor advertising it but and idea occured to me: why is it that harry and voldie have to kill the other? why? why one can't survive with the other alive? stay with me...

why did j.k mention that neville and harry were born on the same day? it occured to me, i do not doubt harry is the one who could kill voldie. say he does... lets say harry kills voldie. but then all of voldies' powers and evil goes into harry... harry becoms evil and neville kills harry? that would be sooooooooooooooooo crazy!! and j.k would finish with the series once and for all... what do you think??

and oh about snape...well he was a death eater so he'd know about voldie. and he doesn't seem to be quaking with fear so he may have a reason behind it. maybe voldie can channel into the person calling him or the person next to the person calling him... i dunno. sort of like the movie candy man (anyone saw it?) or bloomin' mary. if u call their names into a mirror 5 times in a row they appear to you?

WOW loony_lupin
that is really smart
i wonder why all of the death eaters are scared to say voldemorts name too? they always call him the 'Dark Lord'
i just think there must be something more than just being afraid of him
i think its something about his name... you know how he made it up as an anogram of his old one?
i gotta go
luv the ideas so far
keep it up :flowersmile:

kinda like the Source in Charmed?
yeah, that could work, but it would be really depressing
what if he got the powers, but used them for good
that would be a happy ending

Geez! All I can say is Geez! You guys have been very very busy I can tell. And for once I have nothing to add exept that I really do doubt that Sirius is still alive. I don't know why, but I still don't think that he'll come back later or anything. So, umm, *still speechless* keep up the good work!

Honestly, I think our minds are going to be so warped by the time the sixth book comes out that we won't be able to differentiate between what JKR wrote and our own theories. (Pure Craziness)

i just finished CoS ... and umm... a little detail that might be important: voldie made up "i am lord voldemort" in his hogwarts days, and used it with his close friends. hrrrm?

i disagree christiane
he might be dead
but ur forgetting dis is harry potter n nothing ever is simple. so he might be dead i dont know but there is definitely more to discuss.
n cheers me4ron.
n im just loony lupin, no _ in the middle

n i realli realli dont recall jk saying ' sirius is dead'
she says the character in book 5 who dies
the DE goes on abt how they were fighting the animagus black- now she might have done dis to torment us but like i said
there is definitely loads more to discuss

That's a really, really good parallel theory!

i don't think sirius is alive... i think he is very much dead but maybe in book 6 harry will find a way to communicate?

by the way... anyone know or have any idea as to why nearly headless nick was beheaded? :o what did he do??

You know Sirius is cool, that is a really good question. And I am not able to help you out with it at all, sorry. You know, we take everything for granted in books, but we hardly ever stop to wonder why it is that way, you know? So, sorry, but I can't help ya there. Anyway,

That's a very good idea about the Stubby Boardman article, so hats off to you whoever said it( sorry, can't remember). Anyway,

same hats off to who sed the stubby boardman thing i thought the same i even got this girl in my class who sed he's dead to start think about it cuz we really don't know what that veil thingy was o an' Sirius is cool that is a good question

well it was on halloween... maybe he cast a spell and the muggles got mad
i dunno

[font=Impact][size=1][color=red]thats really interesting. how do we post imgs on the boards? it won't let me

I didn't realize it was on Halloween, maybe it was like a whitch-hunt thing or something, but instead of hanging him, he was supposed to have his head cut off. Or maybe it was some political matter, after all, he is SIR Mimsyyadda yadda yadda. Doesn't that signify like some rank or something?

I was reading a couple chapters in OotP last night, and I found somethings that might interest a few of you. Now, just remember that I am not a professional at this. Okay, enough preface;

So, in the part where Luna and Neville and Ron and so oon and so forth are running away from the Deatheaters, before the Oreder gets there, did anyone else ever wonder why it was that Luna was the only person not to have been hurt???

And another thing:

I don't think Dumbledore apparated when he was fighting Voldemort, because when Witches and Wizards apparate and dissapparate, there's like a pop or something, and if you notice, Dumbledore doesn't 'pop' when he was fighting Voldemort, neither in the first book in the very first chapter. It just said with a swish of his cloak he was gone.

One more thing:

In the chapter of Dumbledore and Voldemort's face-off, and when Harry is being possessed by Voldemort, Harry is yelling out to Dumbledore to just kill him,(helped no doubt by Voldemort). Harry yells to Dumbledore to just kill me, and then, he thinks, so I could see Sirius again. After that, he isn't bothered by Voldemort any more. It says in the book that "and as Harry's heart fills with emotion, the creatures coils loosened and the pain was gone." Even when he looked Dumbledore in the eyes a short time after in his office, the creature'did not rise up inside of him'. Could this be what JKR was talking about in the interview that I mentioned a while back? That there is something really imortant, but no one has ever actually said it. Well, could this be it?

Well, anyway, thanks for hearing me out!

I dont get the thing about the really important thing..what does JK say in that interview..what does that have to do with that??'


*no confused smiley**confused*

i dunno if this helps but in book two nick is trying to join a club called the "head hunt" or something, its for beheaded huntsmen.

interesting enough, the guy who is in charge of that (and yes, appears in at least two different scenes) is named patrick delaney-podmore. as in, sturgis podmore. think this could have any signfigance.

i still stand by my sirius-is-abducted theory pretty strongly.

Ok, the interview that I mentioned a while back said that there is something incredibly crucial to the Harry Potter series. She said that she has looked into different chat rooms and forums, and she said that some people have gotten really close to the thing that she was talking about, but didn't get it exactly. Does anyone think that this(this being what I mentioned in my previous post) could have anything to do with it?

I also noticed a couple other things, one I forgot to post earlier and another that I think could be added on to what I mentioned earlier.

Ok, when Harry goes to Dumbledore's office in one of the last chapters of the book( irght after Sirius died) Phineas says something like he thought that only the rightful headmaster could come into the office. Foreshadowing, maybe?

Okay, now the something that I want to add to my previous post.

While I was reading the chapter after the one where Sirius dies, I noticed how Dumbledore said that Harry's being able to feel emotion is his greatest strength, and how he kept making Harry madder and madder. I also realized that Dumbledore would makeeye contact with Harry, and Harry didn't feel Voldemort's hatred for him. Hmmm, a clue maybe?

that is really smart Ian about Dumbledore
i also noticed that in the 1st book, when he finds Harry at the mirror of Erised again, he says that he doesnt need an invisibility cloak to become invisible
*hint**hint*
i think he is a lot more powerful than we know of

gooooooo ian!! hehe sorry a little to excited. great job ian!! :flowersmile:
i wish if j.k could see us... wonder what would she say. and a big thumbs up for ninak! :flowersmile: :up: i never noticed the podemor thing! but i wonder what it could mean? the person they thought was sirius and the guy in charge of the headless hunt are related.

i agree with ilovemalfoy... sirius is gone but maybe there are ways of communication...

however, there is something that has been on my mind... what happened in privet drive? we know something did, because in ootp miss bones at harrys' hearing said:"we have no records of any witch or wizard living in little whinging, other than harry potter. that situation has always been closely monitored, given... given past events". page 131, chapter8 british version. ha!!! so what do you think? i think maybe voldies' old head quarters were there or smth. :ermsmile: :wacko:

i mentioned it befor but nobody commented as there were no brilliant minds like u guys around! and i really want to know what might have happened :flowersmile:

You know Sirius is cool, I never really thought of that. WAY TO GO!!! It's weird how we take so much stuff for granted and not even question it, you know?

Also, ninak, very interesting on your part too.

You guys are so great! This is so much fun, just being able to try to figure out different things!

gooooooo ian!! hehe sorry a little to excited. great job ian!!
i wish if j.k could see us... wonder what would she say. and a big thumbs up for ninak! i never noticed the podemor thing! but i wonder what it could mean? the person they thought was sirius and the guy in charge of the headless hunt are related.

i agree with ilovemalfoy... sirius is gone but maybe there are ways of communication...

however, there is something that has been on my mind... what happened in privet drive? we know something did, because in ootp miss bones at harrys' hearing said:"we have no records of any witch or wizard living in little whinging, other than harry potter. that situation has always been closely monitored, given... given past events". page 131, chapter8 british version. ha!!! so what do you think? i think maybe voldies' old head quarters were there or smth.

i mentioned it befor but nobody commented as there were no brilliant minds like u guys around! and i really want to know what might have happened

comment people!!! im guessing nobody saw it..more like hoping. by the way the potters were attacked and died on halloween. interesteing,eh? im re-reading book1 and there is another thing i noticed, when voldie was defeated weather became rainy (book 1), in book6 however, voldie came back and suddenly there is a drought (isn't brittain supposed to rain like alomst all the time, u'know no drought or anything like that?

I never noticed that they were killed on Halloween! That's very perceptive of you! Hat's off to you!!! You know, I think I'm all out of ideas. Isn't that depresssing? Don't worry! I'll go copy some off of other forums around the net and I'll be sure to let you know. Well anyway, thats all folks!

(Oh, this is the edited part)

I was wondering about that too., The whole things at Privet Drive. Very interesting theory.

thank you! atleast someone appreciates this.

bye the way, i don't know if j.k didn't mean to di it but in the book 1, when harry is in the hospital talking to dumbledore. dumbledore says thats harry delayed voldies' return so another might fight a battle which seems like a losing battle...anyways u check it. it was eomthing like that. this got me thinking: "another"?? isn't harry supposed to do the fighting? who is the other?
thanks ian, ur great.. :flowersmile: