yup

Why?, because he was a bit bitter?. Or because of the pensieve?. Or both?

I think it was because of the way he treated Harry.

Any deathw ill suck for someone, but she was to kill people or else it would not be a war.

yeah he did. he didnt kill pettigrew,and he served 12 freakin' years in azkaban for it. he didnt ask for it, but it happend and yes he had all rights to be mad about it all. as u know he is not one who likes to be ''caged''.

i agree but even if u aren't one who likes to be "caged" i think anyone would still be mad for spending that long in a prison. and it's not exactly like a normal prison like we have this one tries to drive u insane.

I really don't think that we have seen the last of Sirius, though. Even if Rowling doesn't bring him back, I think that he will somehow play an important part in either of the two upcoming books.

I felt really sorry for Sirius I even cried and my friends called me a sook (wrong spelling).
I wish he didn't die I reckon Mad eye should have coz he's really old and like he had a good run in his days so yeah

yeah but I think that there must of been a specific reason for Rowling to kill off Sirius. I don't think she would "just" do it. And as for Mad-eye, he is an important member for the Order. I think that we will be seeing more of him in action in at least one other book.

yeah your right but I love him so much..........no fair

I understand. Before I read the book, I was talking with my friends about the death last year. And I said that I thought that it was going to be Sirius. No one believed me....well, I mean I didn't really believe me. Sometimes it sucks to be right. :ermsmile:

yeah JK deff has a reason for killing off sirius. theres gotta be... or she just didnt find a way to clear him... I'm re reading OOP now and ahhh its so nice to have sirius alive again. ((lol)) u get what i mean...thank god its books, i love reading Prizoner of azkaban when we are introduced to sirius and goblet of fire and OOP. except the last of oop when she kills him off....darn it...i hope she explains in the books that we get alike: ohhh so thats why she killed him off...

otherwise i will have to ask her. hehe.

i said, i hope its nt sirius, it cant be! darn it...

thar's a great idea and everything, but they did'nt hhave the time turner then.hermione handed it back in their 3rd year,remember? :sorcerer:

JKR has made the concept of using Time Turner very confusing....I mean things can be made very different by simply using the Time turner

Same for me too!!

See I dont mind Sirius dying because i am all so positive that we will see him again.....personally i didnt really like him as much as snape......snapes almost a more developed character.

i would like to think we would see him again...BUT theres n bringing back the dead even in the magical world as it says in the book. so unless it turns out sirus escpaed form back there, although i dont see it as possible...(and my being a massive sirius lover) i wish somehow we will hear form him...atleast get a settlemeant on why him....JK, pease, i need to know , hopefully the next books will ''explain'' why sirius had to go....wish he could come back somehow...portrait or something....

still...i want HIM back, the alive him....

i re read oop now and ahhh, heis so fantastic!!! he really makes the books for me even mor fabulous, his character is someone i love.he is funny in a sarcastic way which i love, he loves trouble, not afraid to speak his mind and he under that he is also such a caring person. also abit like a child. *mwahhhh**

JK said someone will die and someone has died. All these theories that someone used the polyjuice potion and that Sirius apparated in time are rediculous. He's dead.
Personally it doesn't bother me! He wasn't developed enough and I really hated him through most of PoA. I guess some of that hate is still in me, even though he is innocent. I hope JK doesn't target someone I like...

yeah, snape is a very interesting character..

anyway, back to sirius. i really want sirius to return, but, remember that jk cried after she wrote the death, so he might not return "physically"...but if he doesnt come back, PoA would have been a bit pointless, because most of it is about sirius, but he hasnt actually done alot for the whole story, sure hes guided harry when he needed help and offered his house to the order, but he hasnt done anything "major".

well, i dont know, thats just what i think...

well alot of people love sirius, cause he IS infact a fabulous character IF u understand him. thats a must. when we found out in POA at the end that sirius was harrys godfather and wasnt evil afterall, i was liek: yayyyyy, love you sirius! after hating him through the whole book,for thinking he was gonna kill harry and was evil. non of it was true, so he started with blank sheets when we found that out, for me atleast.

no even though she dont bring back sirius in some form poa would never be pointkless. books are like this, introducing characters, and letting some go...there just aint room for everyone all the time...sadly...i find it really sad and since jk cried when writing him out i doubt (cant believe I AM saying it) he will come back... but we will certainly get some memory flas backs im sure, to understand sirius mroe,more pensieve things,(hopefully!) so in some way we will probably see him again.

but if it wasup to me, she didnt have to kill him...i didnt mind that he was in and outof the fire, meating them in hogsmead now and then, staying at 12 grimauld place...it rally made the book for me to have sirius there. cause he made harry happy and harry made him happy.

BUT eventuallu knowing sirius(which is the point) it would be abit silly not to have him go after harry, cause thats who he is, he is not one to sit down and not do anything) so JK made it right there, sirius ,his character was one that probably wouldget himself into trouble,(in thsi case, not all his fault, the killing ofhim started with voldemorts false visions in harrys head, kreacher lying) and sirius, as we knew him woudnt sit dow and watch harry head over there. even if that didnt happen sirius would have gone out of the house and gotten into some trouble im sure. but thats him. he wasnt one to sit on his back. sadly at some situations....as this but that was the sirius we knew and i didnt expect him to just sit there and let the rest save harry.

I miss sirius he was a top 10 character to me, i doubt it could put a stopper to death, if they used the time turner and got killed why saving sirius they wouldnt be alive as thier future selves the series would end and jk wouldnt have them take that risk when she ahs insisted that all deaths r final

whoo hoo im a gnome now those are pesky little buggers.. i also agree fully with miss potter

i think that sirius had to die because there was no way to get him released of charges, and he would have spent all of the rest of the books in captivity. i also forsee something in harry's future which will make him want to leave the durselys or hogwarts, and sirius' death will prevent him from doing so. i wonder if the order will remain in the house of black though?? i also must include how much it killed me when sirius died :ermsmile: , but i absolutely love when harry meets luna in the hallway and she says she thinks they will meet again behind the curtain...hmmm maybe i could put that in my siggy