this is just a thing that me and rupertgirl5 have goin on, when you say the s word that she said that starts with se, spell it SIRIUSLY, lol, we do that all the time, and i think that if the time turner was to be used, then it would have been, i just CANT GET OVER THE FACT that it was his COUSIN!!!!!!!!! ggrrrr, that makes me SO MAD!! > > it was his COUSIN!!! aaaggggh, ok im gonna calm down

ok u guys i am just as angry and hurt as u are but realize this ms rowling did this for a reason. everything she has done in books something always comes up later. so i think until book 6 comes we can just hope that something good is gunna happen

I wasn't the slightest bit effected, when Sirius showed up at the Department of Mysteries I knew it would be him. Even if i weren't expecting it I don't think I would have been upset, I never liked him as much as everyone else seemed to.

who ever started this topic just spioled the book for lots of people. Please dont do it again you just gave something realy important away and know we wont have a chance to cry. >

I cried. It was so sad!

yeah since we all knew there was going to be a death, his death didn't really shock me. i was like ah.. oh well. now if it was Lupin, i would have been sad.

i cried and put the book down then i had to finish it i cried everytime it mentioned him

I cried after his death, my friend and i think that Harry is going to be suicidal in the next book. We think he will attemp to kill himself with the Ak curse but it wont work because it only works when deep down in your heart you want to!

I HIGHLY doubt this theory. First of all, it was pointed out that the time turner was very dangerous and people ended up killing there past selves. Second of all, in the third book, there were holes, where they actually didn't see the things happening, but assumed it and when they went back with the time turner, the holes were filled and things were understood. In the final chapters in book 5, I didn't see any holes where this could happen and Harry watched with his own eyes see the person fall to his doom. Also, I doubt JK would use the time turner to get him/her back. I personally see that this person is gone from the books and will only survive in memory or death. JK even said that there is no way to bring back the dead. Also, why would she cry over the death if he/she wasn't really dead?

The death was stupid, in my opinion. There was nothing to it... not blood... no agony. No nothing. He just POOFED and fell into a veil... Stupid.

I don't think J.K would do that(sorry ,it's my oppinoun).That's just too obvious. I think she'll either find a new way so that Sirius comes to life or a ghost. I just hope that he's able to talk to James an Lily, or something like that. I don't know, we'll just have to wait till the next book comes out :ermsmile: :brokenheart: :crysmile: :crysmile: . When will that be???????????lol.



*0*Lauren*0*

i dont care if it's unlikely, if it saves **** (can we say his name now?) then i am rooting 4 it!

sorry folks. I am almost possible it wont happen! I mean JKR broke down crying after she wrote the death. The Death people! As much as I would like him to come back I honestly dont think he will come back.

Isn't the Ministry still on the lookout for ******?
I mean, and isn't it ilegal to use just the time turner for every reason? Doesn't Dumbledore say things like that happen?
Cedric died, they didn't use the timeturner for him back.


Even though I dearly care for ******, it's not like all of are problems are going to be solved with the time turner. Jo (a.k.a. J.K. Rowling)wouldn't make it that way. There is going to be drama continuing out through the books.

Yes...I cried hysterically. I had to go sit in my Mom's lap until the shock was over.

After 2 days of having finished the book, I'm still not myself. I've felt as if I've lost one of my greatest friends.

I am really depressed. I don't know what's wrong with me. I mean, it's just a book!

But, I was thinking...since Rowling made it a SPECIFIC point that Sirius fell into the veil, I think that that was a way of saying that Harry will communicate with Sirius in the future.

yes i cried. i really do not understand why jk wanted to kill someone who is so close to harry as close as a father to him. i hope all of this will be explained in book 6.

No one actually knows...Maybe Sirius ...might come back in the sixth book :ermsmile:

I cried!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! My friend told me and so I was prepared for it, but when I knew it was about 2 happen I started crying and couldn't stop for ages!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Now I feel really depressed!!!!!!!!!!!!

i cried soooooooooo much
even after i finished reading it and just thought of him i did

I didn't. I was told before I got up to that part so I was prepared but I don't think I would have even if I didn't know

SIRUIS has to come back somehow
!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think his death has something to do with the plot of the story. Perhaps, indeed he died but his death is goign to do something. I mean, Joanne could have been faking it when she was crying about killign a charachter off..

I agree...I thought it was a bit of an anticlimax really. I finished reading that section and went "is that it?" I wasn't even certain he was dead until I completely finished the book and thought he must be!!

Didn't effect me at all. Yeah, it's sad and everything and I feel sorry for Harry but I think Rowling could have written the death a bit better.

That's just my opinion.

I agree leilou70 I wasn't completely sure he was dead, and then when I finished I was really confused so I read that part again. I guess I was expecting a drawn out death and was a bit dissapointed, but then I heard JK at the Albert Hall and she said death is usually sudden and unexpected and I realised that yeah it is, so in a way the death was pretty true to life and in that way makes it a brilliant book.