Er...

I wonder if the film-makers will make Kreacher say,"My precious..." They screw up lots of things, so it's likely.

If they keep him in after all they cut dobby and winky from GOF

Beh...you have a point. But they have a new script writer for no.5 so there is hope. Steven Kloves scripts weren't exactly my pepsi twist. They were pretty corny. Meh...no dobby, no winky, no spew...no drunkiness, no sockiness? Boo...

i'll think they will write him in because there's not that many magical moments in OotP unlike GoF where there was so many things to include

True, very true. But I have this nagging hunch...somewhere along the line they'll make a point to cutting him or making his role very short. In the Cos, Dobby was in three five minute scenes and he had like four small lines in each one. Grr...and he's my 2nd favorite character too...Ron being the first of course but it seems like as the books get longer, the movies get shorter. I think if Peter Jackson directed them they'd be less immature and would stay more accurate to the books but I doubt he will.

iam glad there is no dobby or winkly i hate the whole SPEW thing!

They're so cute! Why must you hate them! I think they're fun to glomp. Though SPEW had its annoyingness sometimes. I think Emma Watson is too busy glomping herself to care about the elves.

i just dont think there is much point to the story! my opinion!

^ ya mee too, the whole SPEW thing is really quite pointless and annoying but dobby and kreature add a lil sumthing to the books. ....ya and i could acctually seee keira knitely as tonks......and before the PoA movie came out i really pictured sirius as being like johnny depp( such a good actor!!) in edward sissor hands- without the sissors ov course.!

LOVE THE ELVES! But you can throw tomatoes at Kreacher. he's a meanie-poo.

^ oops....and without the scary hair....well you know...if the hair and makeup ppl are really good so they could make him look like how the book describes sirius....but o well Gary Oldman is really good too.

Gary Oldguy was good but I was reminded of Aragorn a little too much and the laughing posters weren't scary...they were hilarious.

I love Gary Oldman, but i thought he was robbed of a good preformance in PoA, he had too few lines!!

Yeah but at least he's not cut from GOF. The elves are! I must mourn the loss of them!

He kind of is all you see is the shape of his face in the fire, and then his voice is all weird like Voldermorts was in PS

How creepy...

yeah it is!...it's nothing like i imagined it!

I feel like hitting the film makers with an oversized ham! it's like they're only targeting their movies to 10 and under now by making them shorter and more crappy and corny.

^ well i wouldn't say they were crappy...but i agree with the shorter part, i would sit and watch it for five hours if they included everything nd it was good...

Me too! I second that! Lord of the Rings was three hours long but it was pretty accurate and it kept me interested and I was ten when I first saw Fellowship of the Ring and many ten year olds can sit still but a lot of younger aged kids who are like five or six like HP and it needs to be shortened down for them so they'll be able to understand and they won't grow ancy but then it ruins the movie for the older viewers. I don't want to blame innocent little children but they're one reason the movies are shorter.

^yeah but the could have made GOF longer if that was the case becasue that's a PG13 which is probably a 12 here, but i don't think were quite as strict over here like they are in America!

*sigh* I suppose so...I just wish the movies were more longer and thorough. The plotlines are getting choppier and choppier. The beginning scene of POA lasted 5 minutes at a max counting the part when Harry was stomping angrily away.

^yeah but by the look of the trailer for GOF it mkes up for it!!

It's still a choppy length. The same as POA.