id say 8\10

i would give it 8/10

wow, i hated this movie! i was so dissapointed in it. it did not stay true to the book for me at all. it was weird to. i didnt like it at all. i would have to give it a two out of a ten. sorry.

the prisoner of azkaban was pretty good so i rate a 9.5.

I love/hate PoA. I hate the fact that they messed with the story line so much and the scenery. But I also love the movie as a movie, it was good and not as little kidish as the first two. So I guess I give it 7/10.

I would give the movie a 7/10. I totally agree with you lovexobsession

i liked the movie it was full of action and you dont know what willo happen next it is so .......great! igive it a 8/10 i cant wait for the next movie!

the movie was fantastic in fact there is yet a HP movie to prove me wrong ROn was so cute and so was Harry, but i especially loved the scene where Hermione knocks Melfoy out that was a classical moment

i give a 5 out of 10.....it was absolutely horrid! they skipped everything that i wanted to see! i guess one good part was Hermione punching Malfoy, but i really wanted to see some more action.....absolute the worst hp movie ever! I HATED IT!

10/10
I loved Ernie and the Shrunken Head. Also I liked the rollerskating spider/bogart. It was great.

it like nothing i seen before. i give it a 10/10

Such a good movie. 9/10 because Alfonso did such a good job but he cut alot of my favorite parts out. =(

It seems that lately, many a number of people have been bashing PoA for the drastic changes, the cut scenes, the artsy direction. I remember after my first viewing, I hated it. All those things drove me nuts, I mean, how can you do PoA without the Mauraders! Blasphemy!

But then I saw it again, and I was able to let go of the changes, and what I enjoyed was a more mature Harry Potter, a movie that matched the tone of the book. Alfonzo Cuarón successfully captured the darker world in which dementors guarded Hogwarts and the effects of reliving your darkest moments. The previous two films were fun and adventurous, but the later books were darker, grittier, and Cuarón was the perfect director to take that on.

Notice that every film afterwards used his vision of the school, his robes, his grounds, his wands. He strived to make Hogwarts more real than fantastic. Sure it had the mystery and wonder, but it had a familiarity that grounded the events in the real world.

The picture also was a harsh reality that plots needed to be dropped. The books were getting longer, and longer, and somewhere things needed to be dropped. Sure many were angered, and upset, but more and more elements were cut in the later movies. The trimming needed to start somewhere, and unfortunately Cuarón had that burden on his shoulders.

So I give the movie a solid 8.5/10, it wasn't perfect, I did miss some elements, but I loved what the movie meant for the rest of the franchise.

Well I would only give it 3/10 because there were only 3 things I liked.

1) Harry's flight on Buckbeak, the scenery, the music and Harry's look of joy were wonderful
2) Remus Lupin- He was brilliant, the scene with Harry on the bridge, the Patronus lessons and the Boggart class were so good.
3) Aunt Marge and the scene with the Dursleys. That was well done.

I hated the Shrunken Heads, the Toad Choir, Ron being reduced to a pathetic, cowardly clown, Hermione stealing all the lines and the limelight, that fat kid with the stupid lines, all the parts that were cut and ESPECIALLY, that horrible Freeze Frame at the end!

i really love this movie ! probably the best one !
i would saaaaay 10/10 !
it was excellent !

I give PoA a 10. I loved this one too. It was detailed greatly and did the book some justice.