I think it's a bit overrated if you ask me.

I love any HP movie that is and ever will be.
Rating: 1,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000, 000,000,000,000,000/10

POA is without a doubt the best HP film so far

POA was definitly the best they were much better actors in it and COS was good but idk POA was just so much better the special effects were really good too

6/10. Enough to keep me interested but losing the real feel of the book. A bit rushed too. I prefer the Chamber of Secrets and Socerer's Stone. If it's precise and true to the book then I'll sit through 7 hours of it. I didn't like how shorten PoA was.

3 1/2 stars / 5 stars

i think this is the best HP movie ever, altho' it's a bit rush and i don't like 2 things

1. the firebolt scene
2. hermione

otherwise, it's all okay

HP 1 and 2 altho' stay true to be book, i've found it a bit boring

i think each HP movie should be more than 2 hours long, because the books contains so many elements critical for the storyline and they seem to left it out because of the time constaints.

overall i like PoA, tho' i'm not really crazy about it, but the director (Cuaron) seems to know what's he's doing.

^^^i agree...9/10 for PoA...but i absolutly LOVED the werewolf scene til the end!!! LOVED IT!!!!!!!!

10/10
When I first saw te movie at the premiere in London, I went absolutely bonkers and flipped out! I became obcessed over it and sa it again becaus I loved it so...

I liked it because it was a harry potter movie but they obviously didnt read the book cause if they read the details of it then it would have been alot better!!! *out of breath* lol

I didn't like how they completely hacked away at the plot in the book but then again there was some really good acting. I also liked how in the PoA, they kept most of the movie in darkness like the whole film was filmed on days that had an overcast sky, it brought out the mysteriousness that should be in a HP movie. But the whole thing they did to the plot really irks my feelings on the movie. So I'm gonna rate it as a 7/10.

i really like the movie..it was darker than the previous ones but it was good!!!!..of course they let many things out..but what do u spect they had 2.. rating 7.5/10

I believe PoA was a good movie, although not thaaat wonderful movie everyone talks about.

Don't get me wrong, I love it, and I believe it is a wonderful development from Chris Columbus. I really hated the way he handled the first two movies, but this is a discussion for another thread.

Regarding PoA I like the fact that Cuaron understood that the audience had changed and that he needed a more adult approach to the story. This was a wonderful development. Besides, the filming was very neat, and I liked -unlike many others- that Cuaron took a artistic licence, let me call it this way, to include things of his own vision. I think that is wonderful, because it makes the films richer. I believe that if you want something faithful, there is nothing like the book. Otherwise, be open for some changes .. although I like them to be slight changes.

I would give this movie a 7 1/2 over 10.

I liked it but I cannot say I liked it as much as I wanted to. I believe that the director should have followed the book a bit more. I liked the plot behind it with the warewolve and sirius. But all around it was a great film

I loved it! I give it 8/10

This movie was my personal favorite.... until the fourth movie came out. All of the movies, other than the fourth, seemed so short though! I give this... drumroll please! I give this movie an..... 9/10!

Ok, I'm sorry, but Alfonso Cuarón? Not my favorite director. He's hardly directed any movies at all...I was expecting this to be really good, but I was a bit disappointed. Blackouts? Come on Alfonso, even I know that it loses the attention of the audience. I mean, sure, it added a certain flare of mysteriousness, but it just bored me after a while.

I certainly agree that one should not try to use the book to much for references when it comes down to the movies. Unfortunately, there is no way most movies can do justice to most books - just too much material to cover. I also agree that, by leaving out the Marauder's Map was a huge loss, and that not to explain the Padfoot, Prongs, Moony and Wormtail connection was a big mistake. But, on the whole, this film was my favorite because it brought out Hermione's character strengths without impinging on Harry's. I also loved the Hippogrif flying scenes and loved the concept of the timeturmer. I have to give it a 9/10.

I owuld give it like a 9. I really liked the POA cause it had a lot of humor in it! I loved the Mauraders map scene with fred and George! I also like when Ron wakes up and he is like "spiders spiders they want me to tap dance!" I love it! But yes at the same time they missed a lot in the movie. but i think all the movies will be like that cause the books are huge! But i think if they just put all the details in it would be better. Even though it would be a lot longer, the hp fans would be a lot more satisfied!

Hmm... i don't know... an 8.5.
I rate it an 8.5 because the movie was good with the special effects, but it wasn't scare your socks off movie like the prevous 2. GoF had more scary events and made me squeal in the theater. This movie didn't. I thought it sort of sucked. But many parts had humor. I personly enjoy Dre Head. I've seen this movie most then the others so it's probably better to me.

It was a nice movie. 7/10

to be completely honest, it wasnt all that good. I mean, the movie itself was pretty good.... although not much went on in the areas of explanations, but overall it was ok. However, I REALLY didn't like how much was cut out. Way too much was missing and what was there wasn't right (in my mind) at all. Plus, there were WAY too few Snape scenes.... the dratted director cut out almost all of his parts :@ argh. That made me mad. I'd give this movie a 7/10, and thats being generous. I had expected alot more because of all of the books,this is my fav.

9/10

it was a cool movie

i was a little disapointed.....i thought it was going to be the best but i think its overrated.......i wish they had done better because i love the book so much and i didn't see the book and the movie have a conection....it was just to off........but i love the acting its just the director.....
holly

i give it a 9 /10 i love it i repeated it every night ova the school holidays loved it loved it