I vote goblet of fire 9.7. mainly in the field of it being better than the other movies.

I liked it. 9/10.

Just because it was diffrent from the book. No dobby or sirus was in it as much as the book.

7.0

Well of course they had to cut some parts from the movie but it seemed that they everything. Literally. And no Ludo Bagman? The "Veela Dance" (i.e. the performance by the Madame Maxime's students on their arrival at Hogwarts) was embarrassing. The World Cup - it didnt' seem as if there was one. Everything important has been chopped out of the book. And what about S.P.E.W? It ought to have been there. And the new Dumbledore - Heavens help me. he didn't seem at all like our dear ole calm Dumbly. It seemed he loved to shout.

But the movie had its share of good points. The arrival of the Durmstrang students was a nice touch to the plot. David tennant played a brilliant Bart Crouch. Jr. The tasks were managed quite well. The scene at the graveyard was quite good too even though the deat heaters didn't seem too much afraid of Voldemort as they should have been.

So the movie had its fair share of faults and good points. I rate it 7/10 (as I've mentioned befor).

Maxie

15/10

thhe best harry potter movie ever made I loved it I watch it almost every day

I think that GOF was by far the best out of all of them, but lots of people don't like it because of the fact that it left out the whole S.P.E.W thing. well, if that was in the movie, then the movie would have been 3 and a half hours long. not really what they wanted. so, they took out S.P.E.W because it was unecessary for the final outcome, the return of voldemort. So, i think that they did a good job of weeding out the irrelevent thing. Plus, before they started filming, the script had to be written, which was approved by J.K.Rowling herself. If she thought that it was okay, then we should just trust her judgment, because she wrote te books.
:-)

by the way, i thought that it was a 9.3
it had its faults.
like dumbledore pushing harry!!!! what was up with that?! that made me mad.
yeah.
:-)

Well to GoF I definently have to give it a 8..9 cause they missed out alot of important things. I really disliked that.

*points to Tara's post*

Remember no rate = spam

i love it

it didnt really no wat was goin to happen next . so i kept reading and it had reall mystery. i think it is the best one yet.the goblet of fire is a great movie/ book to read and watch
i give it a 9.3/10 because it was interesting myserious and strange in a nice way

i loved it

it was good but left out a lot of things that were funny , interesting and important like the S.P.E.W club and little things like that but overall i would probably give it a 7.5/10

I loved this movie from start to finish. So much of it was exactly as I'd pictured it from reading the book it was downright scarey- how'd they get in my head like that?!?!

The depth of character played by Alan Rickman is amazing this time, he's always been a deep character - hard to pigeon hole, but this time, WOW! Kudos to all involved!! (I loved the head thumping scene- I felt Alan was barely able to contain his glee in this scene- having to look stern for the part.)

Toodles!

Sue

I'll give it a 8.5. It left out so many important things!!! I read the book again after the movie, and the book was awesome, and the movie didn't cut it. They left out S.P.E.W. completely, the maze was disappointing, and the World Cup could've been better. I know that they have a time limit and they can't include everything, but it could've been longer. The LOTR films were very long, and they still did great. I'd rather have a longer film that includes at least the most important stuff, then a short film that leaves a lot out. I was just very dissapointed. They left out too much imprtant stuf!f!!!

And other thing I didn't like was Dumbledore. In the books, he has always been calm and wise, but then in the movie, he just ran up and shook Harry and yelled at him. That was definately something Dumbledore would never do, and I hated it.

10

this was the best movie ever. everything was just perfection. theres a reason its the fastest selling dvd of all time

i do miss john williams though. he was incredible.

but emma gave her best performace.

cant wait till the next one! cheers!

7.9



Well, I was impressed with the things that they put in the movie, but I believe that the action scenes shouldn't be the entire movie. So many things were left out, I was a bit disappointed with that.

9.0 brill well done

9.5

It was an EXTREMELY good movie--the best one yet, I'd say. The graveyard scene was a little scary but exciting and cool all the same. I'd be able to watch the movie thousands of times without getting sick of it once!

World Cup - brilliant! When the Crowd roared out "Krum! Krum!" I wanted to yell too. Harry versus the dragon, more exciting than the book, rare praise indeed.

BUT they cut out SPEW They cut stuff from PoA and GoF is a bigger book, so I expected some cuts, but to completely cut Hermione Crusader for Justice to focus exclusively on the Yule Ball, Hermione tries to be a bimbo for one night in her life? So totally wrong. And now the ball scene has spawned an abominable horde of makeover fics. Obliviate Yule Ball.

4/10

HARRY POTTER AND THE GOBLET OF FIRE

not discribable in any other way then THE BEST MOVIE EVER

THANK YOU



10 out of 10

8.5/10

well i really enjoyed it... awsome... nearly as good as the chamber of secrets... which is my all time favourite out of the movies...
what the bad side of it is that there were simple things that they missed or changed... the main two..
1. hermiones periwinkle blue dress... not so blue was it?
2. and when the grave yard scene comes stuffing cloth into harrys mouth didnt quite happen either
3.in the graveyard scene... scraping some blood of harrys leg... instead he cut a slit in harry arm...

apart from those things... that really annoy me, cos all these fans that havent read the books think they know everything... the movie was great... evry word was in the rite place and the wand connection thingy was absoultly fantastic... loved it.

8.5 It had it's great points - fantastic special effects and acting through out but i felt it was missing something.

I give it an 9, because although it was a very good movie, there were things that were omitted that I wish were still in there.

I loved it 9.5!
I just wish they wouldve stuck to the book for the ball.
The acting was great, loved the music and a well done job.