Oh how i wish they were real

i think that is a really good guess and it makes a lot of sense

good logic..

It is really. It's a mixture of logic, common sense and information Jo has previously given us.

Educated informed guess which is probably accurate but very vague - she gives no real solid detailed predictions like the editorial sleuths at Mugglenet.

Interesting...

Though I think some of it is logical based facts ...

I dont think Snape saved Dumbledore's life--he would have mentioned it. But I do agree that Neville is becoming more confident as a wizard and will improve more in the coming books.

I agree, you dont need a fine-picked book analysis to figure that out. Just look at the basic facts and you could conclude that.

Nice logic. Makes me wonder why Dumbledore trust Snape so much....

Thats a very intresting logic it makes good sense im kinda doubting that snape saeved dumbledore i think it has something to do with that just not that.

These are some facts that most of us have figured out ourselves. Its just sort of common knowledge with a bit of opinion. So i hope that she doesnt plan to become something like the next Mystic Meg cause i dont think she'll go very far. Well unless she is willing to be a total fraud that makes up stuff on the obvious and rips everyone off, Cause then i'll have a little competition!

She's got some interesting ideas. I honestly think that both Snape and Neville will have much bigger roles to play now! (I thought Neville was the HBP for a while... ) I can't wait to find out for myself!!

That was an awesome article... she has a lot of possibilities!

Except for the limp, that's how Ah picture Gryffindor. He was so brave he may have gotten into a scrape he couldn't fully recover frome.

ooh those were very good predictions (even though i only read the quotes im reading the full story now...) and i wonder how she'd feel (and the rest of us) if some (or all) were true! (well we'd be ecstatic as well if we though we figured out JKR, but as usual we'll prolly underestimate the amount of twists...) but i think its cool that this got published online even though there are other sites like SS and mugglenet w/theories. i do agree with the part about snape becoming their friend since he used to be a DE... wonder what JKR has come up with... sigh.

oh my gosh... i totally guessed the same thing about Neville. I think that now he has proved himself capable of fighting he will be a fairly big part in the final battle (maybe lol)...

Good guess about Snape. For all we know it could be true... but i agree that something would have happened in the past to prove Snape's loyalty to Dumbledore... oh well (sigh) we'll just have to wait and see (tear) lol

This may sound a little rude but everyone has sort of already established most of that. It's not like we haven't guessed it already. You only have to look the flourish and blotts link to see all that already

xactly

Well, its her opinion. at least we have lots of leads. plus, if it they did come true, she has an archive of it to prove it.

i know..all the stuff has already been disussed loads of times

I think the Snape and Neville part makes sense... However, I'm not sure if that will actually come in the books... Since Neville has already shown great courage and that he is good with magic..

And Snape doesnt actually had to save Dumbledore.. The thing is, Dumbledore trusted Hagrid all along.. And Hagrid didnt need to prove himself to him.. So, that's why I'm not sure about that part.

Sure, it would be awesome to know! hehe

She has quite ome good logic. In fact I thought about it as well. Neville might prove himself to be a better wizard. I thought about Hagrid and Lupin as well but not Godric Gryffindor.

That is a pretty good guess, I just wish they were true!!

A couple of ideas that have poped into my feeble head:
1) Is there a chance that Neville's near progeny of Herbology could lead him to cure his parents?
2) In GoF (I just happen to reread this part this am) Voldemort refers to one DE that has left and will be killed. Is this Snape? Does Voldemort know that Snape is working for the Order? The only mention of DE's not at the circle are the Lestrange's, Barty Crouch Jr., and one who has denounced Voldemort and will also be killed.
3) What is the significance of the gum wrappers given to Neville by his mom? (I know, not very original)
4) Lastly, as Neville gets more proficient with his magic (except potions), I think it will have to be a combo of Harry and Neville that takes out Voldemort. It could have been either in the prophecy, could it be both?

I just don't know, but I love trying to figure it out!

Ooohhh... It's as if JK Rowling was talking...

You know i think it's true... You'll never know... I'm trying to read every speculations that i come about... And every speculations are different, and every peculation is very realistic... So i'm not closing my doors to more specs...

Talking about Half-Blood Prince from the Speculations...

I like the idea of Prof. Lupin being the Half-blood prince... I also liked Godric Gryffindor being the half-blood prince, which can be very realistic since Gryffindor is a very powerful wizard back then... But the fact that he's already dead makes it go down the drain... Anyways, still rooting for Prof. Lupin though...