That would be bad! He's not my kind of director...

I dlidn't think he was doing a REALLY great job with the 5th film. But maybe he'll do better in the 6th and 7th?

I doesn't mind him. I really like OotP but I prefer Spielberg for example

Meh. OoTP was pretty good.

I was kind of waiting for someone else, too. Oh well, maybe there's still hope?

If he does a good job with HBP then that's alright, if not... *sigh*

I won't have an opinion until after I see HBP. OotP was good, but I want the final one to be done right...perfect.

Shannon

Hmm, not too sure.
I didn't like OotP at all.

I'll decide what I think of him after HBP.I'm still iffy about his dirceting of OotP, it was good, but not the best

I like OOTP. You can't put the whole movie down to him. You have to take things like the script and the acting into perspective to.
I wouldn't mind if he directed the last one.

Interesting.........

True, you can't blame an entire movie on the director. I think Steve Kloves is back for HBP, so the screenwriting will be back to its usual superb quality. But I didn't really like the pacing and overall mood of the film. The previous movies had been getting better with each installment, but I thought OotP took a downturn. But I will reserve final judgement until I see HBP.

I liked OotP it was good. But I agree the last one needs to be done good or it will not be good.

I agree so much. All a director does is direct his view of how the movie look and actors should act in scenes. It's up to the cinematographer on how it's shot. There's so many things at play that viewers don't understand. Look twice at a film and all the other elements before you judge the director.

I really enjoyed Order of the Phoenix! I think it was leaps and bounds better than Goblet of Fire. It did a wonderful job of tying all the movies together. I think it'll be great if we get one director for the last 3 movies. It'll keep a consistency that I think is really missing from the series.

Let's hope he's on for the last film!

And John Williams doing the score will tie everything together beautifully!!

ssawwweeeetttt!!! he's one cool cat.

I didn't really like OotP that much...it wasn't as great as the first four ones. If he really does direct DH then he has to do a better job.

i didnt like ootp as much as some of the other films and i really wanted to see someone else take over, but as long as he does better with the last films i dont mind

I would prefer the Mike fellow who directed Goblet of Fire to direct DH. He seemed to get involved more.

Oh thats nice

OotP is my favorite HP film, but DH is my favorite book (OotP is the second). I wouldn't mind seeing him doing DH. It really depends on if the script and things are better.

I don't see what's wrong with him...

I didn't like OotP because of the script. People often put together the acting and script and blame the director. If you ignore that, then David Yates did fairly good.
Besides, it was hard to do OotP. It was the least favourite book of the series acording to certain articles, because it was long-winded and somewhat boring on the whole. Considering what they had to work with, Yates did pretty good.
I honestly loved it when Chris Columbus did the first two movies - I thought the first one was amazing despite so many cuts and changes of the book he did amazing. Too bad he won't come back as director, but he's still in the movies as producer.

So overall I don't mind Yates, he's a good choice out of the director of PoA (for sure if you ask me) and GoF (definitely - to me at least. Very good acting parts as well as shots but I didn't like it that much on the whole).
But out of all of them, Christopher Columbus did the best if you ask me.

So... I do hope Yates does it if Columbus doesn't He can 'redeem' himself with the script having better results (hopefully!)

I suppose I'll have to HBP before I give my opinion.. I was waiting for another director, though.. We'll just have to see how this one turns out.

I'm seriously going to have to wait until I see HBP to give my full opinion on this article because I didn't like how Yates did OoTP so he's got like one more chance of redemption before I start pulling out the torches.

As for the screenplay, I really do NOT like Steve Kloves because you can tell by watching the movies that he's a big H/Hr guy and that's not Canon. I just don't want Kloves to mess up R/Hr in HBP or I will hunt him down.

i think he left out alot in Ootp he didnt show about hermione getting hurt and ron and the brains and.....well you see my point those are the parts i was looking forward in the movie but nooooooooo!