ok who ever said that needs help really quick because that was so not true

ok who ever said that needs help really quick because that was so not true

I think that Michael Gambon was awesome! Sure he could never take the other guys place(forgot his name going blank here.......) anyways i think that that was the best movie out of the HP series. And its not really that bad that they showed Hermione a lot because she wasn't shown that much during the first two movies.

WHAT? what was wrong with the senery i thought it made the film after all Hogwarts is sent in Scotland where it was filmed. u will notice the diffrence in GOF cos it isnt shot here.

i loved POA it was so much better than the first two i cant even explain why. leave the scenery alone it was a great addition to the movie.

I actually didn't like PoA more than the other 2 movies...I thought the other 2 were a lot better...I dunno....I liked them all...I just liked the other 2 more!!

^ same here

i agree with you! ^__^

*Snigger* Totally agree...


I'm sorry but the only dissapointing thing of POA was - the ending. it seemed as thought they jsut squished the Firebolt scene because they forgot about ti or something.. and the freezee frame...Gosh - i didn't like that at all! And i AM A harry-Dan supporter!

I have to agree with some of the points made in that article, such as it was a huge disapointment with the lack of explanation for the Mauders (there was one line in the Shrieking shack, but it went to fast with all the bickering) and Harry's patronus was unexplained. Anyway, I feel that Hermione was over-done, but she was meant to be in this one, but not the way they did it. In the books Hermione struggled to handle her time table and was tired and late and grumpy, which is normal and makes her character real. But in the movies she just seemed to becoming a rebel, without all the emotion. Book!Hermione is one of my favorite character's, but movie!Hermione is fast coming one of my least favorite character's, because she isn't real.
As for that Lupin comment, did this young lady even read the book? Lupin is meant to be 'geeky' (not a fair word to use, though). He is meant to be like Hermione, bossy, but really a softy.
Great as in it really showed their platonic love and brother-sister relationship, totally!

OMG. WHAT IN GODS NAME IS THIS PERSON THINKING??????? PoA was not, i repeat NOT a boring movie. It is, and most of you will agree with me, the BEST Harry Potter movie so far, it outstripes Philosopher's/Sorcerer's Stone and Chamber of Secrets by a mile and a half. This person must be from planet Mars if she found it boring. they mustn't understand the concept.

I LOVE THIS MOVIE !!!! I found a few problems though and im gunna say 2 though
First wen harry just recieved the marauders map frum the twins and the names appear look at moony's name the way its spelled in the movie they spell it mooney there isnt supposed to be an E

Also after Lupin fought off harry boggart and harry is just standing there look at where his scar is. Its on his left but in all the other movies and the beginning and the rest of this one its on the right hmmm

Sorry just had to post this sumwhere

everyone has their opinions but i would have to say I LOVED the 3rd film just as much as the other 2

hmm. i never noticed that Moony was spelled Mooney on the Marauders Map in the movie.. must just be one of those small things that only the most dedicated fans pick. Oh.. wait..... I AM ONE OF THOSE MOST DEDICATED FANS lol. didn't think about that one.

My friend noticed it but I didnt so I went to see it again and I didnt mean to notice the scar thign but i looked at harry and sumthin was wrong and i was like wait a minute and i yelled to my sister his scar is on the wrong side and she thought i was crazy but noticed it too. People say wen they r about to get attacked by moony u can hear the directer say emma and she walks off and says wat but iunno havent noticed it o ya also wen they r in the shrieking shack they said u can see emma say daniels lines yet again i dont kno if its true and Im sry if u guys dont really wanna hear this frum me just thought it was interesting.

I have to say the movie wasn't the best one but I still like it.

I found it a bit boring actually. But then again, the second time I read the book I was a bit bord.
I deffinatly enjoyed the first two films more. I don't know why, they just felt more complete too me. Something about this movie made me feel that it was stuck on fastfoward and it was just dull.

Hmmm, well, I don't think it should be called boring, from the time turner to where Harry and Hermione got back to the hospital wing was SO exciting! espaically where they were being chased by the werewolf. But lets change the word boring to something thats a bit more true. it was so *thinks hard for the right word* serious and uncheerful. It shouldn't be too serious because it wasn't that serious in the book, and it was extremely uncheerful. i think they should have added more color to the story. the story is based inside Hogwarts. The movie hardly showed any signs that its a castle at all. And it also should have had a bit more of a story line, there was none in the movie which greatly disappointed me :ermsmile: They just cut from scene to scean which is a personal insult to me! And as for Lupin, well, they didn't do a good job on him whatsoever! He was supposed to have "shabby robes" which J.K. Rowling kept on mensioning, and should also look very tired. The movie showed neither; he had slightly to big robes but they were in fine condition, and he certainly did not look tired. Ummm, for they showed Hermione more than Harry? Well, to be honest, I think it was good they put alot more of Hermione in the book, in the other two movie she was kind of shunted aside and only Harry was showed. Diffently, DIFFENENTLY PoA was not better than CoS. What in the world are you guys playing at!?


P.S. I think its amazing how touchy HP fans get when they're on the subject whether the movie was good or not. *Rolls eyes*