What do you think will be the fate of the Malfoy family? Are Lucius and Draco going to be killed off and Narcissa run off, never to be heard from again? Is this the end for this great wizarding family? And what about the Blacks?


On or after February 1st.

Done

What do you think happened to Voldy's bodie? It was kinda propped up there in Hogworts while the cleaning went on, then nothing else was said of it. Also, at the end of the epiloge it say this "he lowered his hand absentmindedly and touched the lightning scar on his forehead." Then it ends"The scar had not pained Harry for ninteen years". I bring it up because of the past tense in the word HAD, the scar had not pained him in nineteen years. And why did he absentmindley touch his scar, had he been doing this all along or just this time? It has to do with Voldy because of the past tense HAD not, and IF he had not been touching his scar all that 19 years, why now? And where is Voldy's body? Are we sure there were only 7 horcruxs? I just don't see Voldying like that, becuase Dumbledor said to Tom Riddle in OotP that there are things worse than death. And I kinda took that to mean, Voldy's sub-life while without a body for 13 years. I know I over analze everything (I'm sure this to) but wouldn't it have been worse for Voldy to be in that state than dead. You know, on the train in DH Harry with Dumbledore, and the represention of Voldy's soul at the back of the train car. Please put these to rest for me as I'll nutters obsessing about it.


On or after March 1st.

Done

As requested, here's another discussion idea:

So now that the 7th book is out and most people have read it *and if you haven't then you should expect spoilers by now*, what do you think about Snape's true allegiance? His childhood fascination with Lily? If Snape really did love Lily, then what do you think caused him to become a death eater in the first place?

On or after April 1st

Done

What do you think of Peter's death in the final book? Did his hand turn on him because of the life debt that he owed Harry that he didn't carry through? Did Voldemort know that Peter owed Harry and should he relent his actions (like he did when his hand turned on him) or try to save Harry, it would turn on him. Do you think Peter even knew that he owed Harry a life debt?

On or after May 1st

Done

We got to see a ratehr different view of the Malfoy family dynamic in Deathly Hallows. We saw Narcissa take the reigns while Lucius sat idly by (at the beginning of DH) and they both were in a fury over finding their son at the end. What do you think of this? What does this tell you about the Malfoy family dynamic? Does this change your previous view of the Malfoys at all?

On or after June 1st

Done

How do you think each Death Eater, and even Voldemort himself, would react to Azkaban? How would it change them, if at all? Would Lucius miss his hot oil treatments for his hair? Would Bella's craziness not stand out because everyone was equally crazy? Would Narcissa miss her nail buffer? Would McNair miss maiming small animals? Let us know!

On or after July 1st

Done

Here are a couple possible topics for discussion later -

1 - What do you think happened to the Death Eaters who survived the final battle? Did they flee, go to Azkaban, what? Do you think a new Dark Lord resurfaced later?

On or after August 1st

Done

2 - What do you think were the basic flaws that led to the Dark Lord's undoing? What do you think he could have done differently so that he might have triumphed?

On or after September 1st

Idea:

What rules and regulations did you think the Death eaters have in their gang?



On or after October 1st

Done

We all know that Lucius Malfoy could have simply been a Death Eater through fear, no matter how much he tried to hide it, but if given the chance to be a leader of men himself, would he stand for the light or dark?

On or after November 1st.

Done!

In the final battle would you have stayed in the castle to help fight or would you have fled?

On or after December 1st.

If you had been in Tom Riddle's place when you found out that you were a wizard what would you have done? Would you be evil or good?

On or after January 1st.

If Voldermort had survived the killer curse in the last book what would his best punishment be Azkaban prison, hanged or how about his soul being sucked out by the dementors.

On or after February 1st

PhoenixRising had these new ideas for FC Discussions:

* Death Eaters and their relation to real-world events
On or after March 1st

* If Voldemort lived today, in our world...
On or after April 1st

* Discuss Prospective Careers for the Death Eaters (and Voldemort)?
On or after May 1st

* If Voldemort worked at St Mungos as a Healer...
On or after June 1st

* Death eaters in the medical world?
On or after July 1st

Ginevra_P suggested this discussion topic:

The younger generation of Wizards & Witches: The Slytherins who left Hogwarts before the war took place, those that fled. Would they want revenge on their parents death? Are they still feeling hatred towards the Mudbloods and Blood Traitors? Do they still believe in purifying the wizarding race? Are they going to build their own society of Death Eaters? Are they going to be looking for a new master?

On or after August 1st