This is a discussion about some questions I thought up but not limited if you all have other questions to discuss post them and we can talk about those too but here are the questions I thought of...

1. Do you think that Dumbledore would have lived if Regalus would not have taken the horcrux? Or if Dumbledore would have died then do you think that harry's self blame/guilt would have been less then it was in the book?

2. Do you think that Draco would have gone to the "good side" if the Death Eaters were not able to come up the tower so soon and then they would have escaped on brooms and it would have ended up with Dumbledore not dying or would they have escape would Dumbledore want to stay for the fight to help all the people he could?

3. Do you think that fleur and bill would have gotten married and gotten Mrs. Weasly’s blessings if bill would not have been attacked?

4. Lastly do you think that Tonks and Lupin would of started going out and gotten married latter if Bill had not been attacked and/or if Dumbledore would have not died?

Thats all of them but like i said if you have more then just ask them!

Okay so i don't know probabaly someone else has noticed (me being totally oblivious to everything haha) SO henizipah Smmith is related to Helga Hufflepuff and everything but what about Zacharias Smith he's in Hufflepuff but it never said he was related to Henizipah...so is he or am i just being crazy?