View Single Post
Old 09-30-2004, 04:21 PM   #1 (permalink)
navya_HPPOA
Hufflepuff
Nogtail
 
navya_HPPOA's Avatar
 
Location: India
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 334
Send a message via MSN to navya_HPPOA Send a message via Yahoo to navya_HPPOA
Default A Mistake in PoA Movie Which I Noticed...

Well,i hope everyone remembers the movie.In the shreiking shack,when sirius was speaking about his dreadful life,snape arrives and shouts "expelliarmus" and sirius gets disarmed without getting blasted off.But after sometime when Snape points the wand at sirius and offers harry to jinx sirius(apparently),harry shouts "expelliarmus" and snape gets knocked off!!How can this be possible according to the books?I mean....a spell should have a same effect irrespctive of time is'nt it?On the contrary....in the novel,harry,ron and hermione disarm Snape at the same moment and as a result snape gets knocked off!!This is a noticable mistake from a HP book reader point of view!!Anyway,what did you guys think about this?
navya_HPPOA is offline   Reply With Quote