SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - Mira Nair apparently NOT in talks to direct OotP

Mikaela · 09-18-2004, 01:01 AM

Quote:

Seriously though I wish they would hire someone who would be true to the spirit of the books and the stories because special effects aside that's why we love the books right they don't come with special effects. It's the characters that we love Harry, Ron, Hermione, Luna, Neville, and especially Ginny in Ootp.

I so completely agree! With every movie, we lost a little of the characters and a gained a little more action... the assumption seems to be that we already had some characterization and that that's enough; but it's not!!

Quote:

I want the great trio to do it. Alan and Kenneth should direct and Emma Thompson should script.

That's is definitely the best idea yet!! There is a team worthy of OotP! :sorcerer: Though I think that PoA is a book with a lot of action and the movie turned out beautifully. Cuaron did a great job, but the movie worked well for non-readers of the books, while us avid fans are a little disappointed with what had to be chopped out.

09-18-2004, 01:01 AM	#19 (permalink)
Mikaela Crup Join Date: Jul 2004 Location: Lurking Posts: 2,107	In Love with Touz \| \| Lil Mikky-Mu Quote: Seriously though I wish they would hire someone who would be true to the spirit of the books and the stories because special effects aside that's why we love the books right they don't come with special effects. It's the characters that we love Harry, Ron, Hermione, Luna, Neville, and especially Ginny in Ootp. I so completely agree! With every movie, we lost a little of the characters and a gained a little more action... the assumption seems to be that we already had some characterization and that that's enough; but it's not!! Quote: I want the great trio to do it. Alan and Kenneth should direct and Emma Thompson should script. That's is definitely the best idea yet!! There is a team worthy of OotP! :sorcerer: Though I think that PoA is a book with a lot of action and the movie turned out beautifully. Cuaron did a great job, but the movie worked well for non-readers of the books, while us avid fans are a little disappointed with what had to be chopped out. __________________ Graphics made by Loki