SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

PattyH. · 09-06-2009, 01:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Vampire_BaD_GiRl

Oh, and I also noticed that when Collin Creevey was killed, it was told in the book that he probably sneaked back to the castle. But they also say that muggleborns didn't learn at Hogwarts, and Collin was a muggleborn!
Yes, JKR definately didn't think about that either.

JK has already answered this one, she was told of this "mistake", and said it was not a mistake.
Both Colin and Dennis Creevey were members of Dumbledore's Army and Neville alerted all members by their coins, so He would have known that they were fighting for Hogwarts, so he returned and subsequently died.

R.I.P. Colin!

And on the Subject of Wands, perhaps some wands were kept by the Ministry guarded by Dementors and she was able to retrieve hers once the Dementors were turned.
Its highly unlike that her wand was snapped and then mended - as Ollivander said no wand can be repair(with the exception of the use of the Elder wand)

09-06-2009, 01:29 AM	#8 (permalink)
PattyH. Niffler Join Date: Aug 2009 Location: London Posts: 2,876 Hogwarts RPG Name: Patroclus Hudson Ministry RPG Name: Prometheus Hudson Magical Law Enforcement	Professional Twirler Mourned and Missed Quote: Originally Posted by Vampire_BaD_GiRl Oh, and I also noticed that when Collin Creevey was killed, it was told in the book that he probably sneaked back to the castle. But they also say that muggleborns didn't learn at Hogwarts, and Collin was a muggleborn! Yes, JKR definately didn't think about that either. JK has already answered this one, she was told of this "mistake", and said it was not a mistake. Both Colin and Dennis Creevey were members of Dumbledore's Army and Neville alerted all members by their coins, so He would have known that they were fighting for Hogwarts, so he returned and subsequently died. R.I.P. Colin! And on the Subject of Wands, perhaps some wands were kept by the Ministry guarded by Dementors and she was able to retrieve hers once the Dementors were turned. Its highly unlike that her wand was snapped and then mended - as Ollivander said no wand can be repair(with the exception of the use of the Elder wand)