SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - Which character is least like the book version?

shortbottom · 08-06-2009, 02:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by astaroth

Yes I do agree with you, the real Ginny from the books is something so very different than the Bonnie Wright Ginny..

But for me (and probably nobody will agree), Tonks is the least book-version-like character for me. I imagined her ..I don´t know. In OotP I was very dissapointed, in HBP even more...

Nice topic, btw

Thanks.
I agree with both of you about Tonks. In both OotP and HBP she comes across as being really filled with angst. Don't know whether that is a reaction to her dilemma with Lupin (in the novel) or not, but they've taken a lot of life out of an enjoyable character. She does call him sweetheart in the film but it only seems in reaction to his pent up anger. Such a shame.

08-06-2009, 02:07 PM	#8 (permalink)
shortbottom Jarvey Join Date: Jul 2009 Posts: 138	To MagicMarauder and Astaroth Quote: Originally Posted by astaroth Yes I do agree with you, the real Ginny from the books is something so very different than the Bonnie Wright Ginny.. But for me (and probably nobody will agree), Tonks is the least book-version-like character for me. I imagined her ..I don´t know. In OotP I was very dissapointed, in HBP even more... Nice topic, btw Thanks. I agree with both of you about Tonks. In both OotP and HBP she comes across as being really filled with angst. Don't know whether that is a reaction to her dilemma with Lupin (in the novel) or not, but they've taken a lot of life out of an enjoyable character. She does call him sweetheart in the film but it only seems in reaction to his pent up anger. Such a shame. Last edited by shortbottom; 08-06-2009 at 02:09 PM. Reason: missing punctuation