SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - Which character is least like the book version?

Beater0 · 08-06-2009, 05:16 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by astaroth

Yes I do agree with you, the real Ginny from the books is something so very different than the Bonnie Wright Ginny..

But for me (and probably nobody will agree), Tonks is the least book-version-like character for me. I imagined her ..I don´t know. In OotP I was very dissapointed, in HBP even more...

Nice topic, btw

I actually agree. I didn't mind Tonks in OoTP, but she seemed really different in HPB. Maybe it was the weird middle-age brunette bob she had going

I also think that Ginny is portrayed weirdly, but I think that has more to do with Bonnie Wright than the script. Although the "open up, you" line was pretty out there.

Dumbledore, as portrayed by Michael Gambon, from PoA through OoTP was quite out of character. I actually kind of liked him in HPB.

08-06-2009, 05:16 AM	#4 (permalink)
Beater0 Ramora Join Date: Aug 2006 Location: East Coast, USA Posts: 394 Hogwarts RPG Name: Sadie Benson Sixth Year	Quote: Originally Posted by astaroth Yes I do agree with you, the real Ginny from the books is something so very different than the Bonnie Wright Ginny.. But for me (and probably nobody will agree), Tonks is the least book-version-like character for me. I imagined her ..I don´t know. In OotP I was very dissapointed, in HBP even more... Nice topic, btw I actually agree. I didn't mind Tonks in OoTP, but she seemed really different in HPB. Maybe it was the weird middle-age brunette bob she had going I also think that Ginny is portrayed weirdly, but I think that has more to do with Bonnie Wright than the script. Although the "open up, you" line was pretty out there. Dumbledore, as portrayed by Michael Gambon, from PoA through OoTP was quite out of character. I actually kind of liked him in HPB. __________________