I gave the movie a 4. It was extremely engrossing and well acted, actually one of the best in the series so far if not the best. What kept me from giving a 5 was the cuts. There were some things I felt were really important to the plot, the main one being the pensieve memory which dealt with Tom Riddle's heritage and the fact that he is himself a halfblood. This is something I really wish had been included, as I feel it is a crucial element and shouldn't have been left out. But then, I could be wrong.