I thought it was a wonderful movie, much better and definitely more moving than the first two. The first two felt like they had been lifted right from the books and smushed onto the screen, with no cinematic or directing interpretation. And the the funny lines in this movie were much more hilarious and well-written than in the first two. Book 3 is my favorite in the series and movie 3 has a good chance of being my favorite movie in the series, as well! Oh, and I thought Thewlis did a good job portraying Lupin. Every fan is going to have a different opinion on what the character is like, and I certainly think that he did a good job acting as the new professor.

However, this 'Katy' is entitled to her own opinion, and I've heard other fans saying similar things that she wrote in her report. You are not expected to agree with her, but the mature thing is to respect her opinion and move on...who cares what someone else thinks?! It's up to you to determine if the movie was good for you or not.