What this girl wrote is total crap!!! cmon Alfonso put all his aweat and blood (well maybe this is a bit emotional i cant find anythin better to say) into making PoA atleast give the guy some credit and everything cant be exactly as written in the book!!! and hte guy turned out a great movie if not perfect but a great movie and how does this girl know majority of hte hp fans dint like the movie if shes amongst a few who didnt

and why is she comparingg it with lotr both are completly different..

i agree with lemondrizzle this girl is a giving Mike Newell a wrong impression of hp fans