SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - First real PoA review from non-book fan

06-25-2004, 08:52 PM

Weeell... first off, it was a great idea to ask a non-HP-Fan for his opinion. But as someone who considers PoA as one of her favorite books and the best part of the HP-Series so far... I have to say that the movie has gaps in the storyline that CAN confuse people.
Example:
Harry talks bout his father rescuing him at the lake when he was with Sirius. In the movie, he was NEVER told that his father was nicknamed Prongs, that he was an Animagus and that he had the shape of a deer. Logically, everyone could have rescued Harry, so why does he think of his father?
I guess most people wont neither mind nor notice, but there would be more examples like this...
I think people who don't know the book or people who don't mind little inaccuracy will enjoy the movie more than i did :whisle:

06-25-2004, 08:52 PM	#16 (permalink)
Lily Lupin Guest Posts: n/a	Weeell... first off, it was a great idea to ask a non-HP-Fan for his opinion. But as someone who considers PoA as one of her favorite books and the best part of the HP-Series so far... I have to say that the movie has gaps in the storyline that CAN confuse people. Example: Harry talks bout his father rescuing him at the lake when he was with Sirius. In the movie, he was NEVER told that his father was nicknamed Prongs, that he was an Animagus and that he had the shape of a deer. Logically, everyone could have rescued Harry, so why does he think of his father? I guess most people wont neither mind nor notice, but there would be more examples like this... I think people who don't know the book or people who don't mind little inaccuracy will enjoy the movie more than i did :whisle: