03-01-2008, 11:38 PM
|
#1 (permalink)
|
 Fan Fiction & Gallery Mod
AD/HEFC/JKRFC Co-Pres.
MOMFC Graphics
SOTS XFileCentaur
Location: Stalking Edward Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 24,341
Hogwarts RPG Name:
Ariana Castior
Sixth Year
Ministry RPG Name:
Emily Castior
Diagon Alley |  Discussion Topic #3 - If you could...
Quote: |
Originally Posted by ndebic If you could change one thing about the books, what would it be?" I know we all think Jo did a great job, but I think everyone maybe had an idea or hope of where things were going that didn't turn out how they expected/ hoped. Perhaps a love interest or a death etc. I think it is something that everyone can contribute to as everyone will have a point of view, even if it is just "it was perfect they way it was." | Discuss away!
Personally I think I'd only change like two things. I was a bit dissapointed with the fact that my house elfs weren't exaplained more in detail. I think there should have been more involvment with them, other than just the whole final battle thing. We didn't know they were thinking of doing it. Perhaps just a small paragraph (or chapter) describing how Kreacher got theem all to agree to fight.
Another thing I would change would be the professors. I didn't like the fact that all of a sudden all the professors went to help. I'm sue there would be bound to be one who would support him, even if only a small bit and the other professors had to help change the professors mind. Though that would change the whole story line too though... um yeah I'd also say how Gilderoy got our of St. Mungo's (if he did) I mean I'm sure he would have helped in the final fight right?
Credit goes to ndebic for the discussion idea |
|  |