 Keeper of Mr Tennant's specs
i give POA 8.5/10
it is a great film but the reason i give it 8.5/10 is because they cut so much out. i didnt feel that anyone was scared of Sirius like in the book. also i didnt like how things were changed like how harry finds out about his parents and Sirius yes it is in the 3 Broomsticks but Ron and HErmione are out side and no one else is in the rooim but Harry (In his cloak) Fudge, McGonagall and Rosmerta. also Black only enters the castle once and u dont even know it is Halloween. the film os also funny which i didnt expect. the best shot of the whole film is the buckbeak flight it is amazing and Glenco is the realy star of POA.
Quidditch was stunning if not a bit short. my other problem with POA was that they cut to much of the adult actors out with theseption of Lupin. it seemd to be rushing threw the film. saying that if u hadnt read the book or forgot some of it u would and will love it. but i also thing it is a film that u need to see more than once. which i am going to do.
then new cast ie Emma Tompson, Gary Oldman, David Thewlis are all great i am not won over by Micheal Gambon. the returning cast are great as exspected.
POA is a great film beatuifully made. i loved it although it dosent sound like it lol.
but is is great. Alfonso did a great job.
__________________  
Icons made by galileo_icons |