View Single Post
Old 02-20-2008, 01:09 PM   #77 (permalink)
Emma C.D. Watson
Gryffindor
Augurey
 
Emma C.D. Watson's Avatar
 
Location: Kent
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 818

Hogwarts RPG Name:
unsorted
Send a message via ICQ to Emma C.D. Watson Send a message via Yahoo to Emma C.D. Watson
Default

Quote:
Originally Posted by dumble101 View Post
I disagree with most of you. I thought PoA was a really good movie. I felt that it captured the book well, my favorite HP film probably. So I'd have to say Alfonso, then the guy who made movie four and then the guy who made movie five. David Yates I think...but I'm not sure.

POA and gof...Cuaron captured the teen/angry harry and how his friends 1st find out d real dangers of being his closest friends...cuaron had style n sensitivity...it showed it poa..
gof captured teen angst/raging hormones so well...newell did the tasks scenes well too...yule ball could b longer...but i so love how emma decended the stairs...real wow...no one could pull tht one off so well...
miss dobby,elves...

ootp was rubbish compared to poa,gof.it lacked plot..ppl complained it was boring in parts...lack cohesiveness..ending rushed thru...they can make it 3 hrs..ootp was d longest book!
Emma C.D. Watson is offline   Reply With Quote