SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - SBFC Topic #16: Kreacher & Sirius' Relationship *post-DH discussion*

BrightestWitch · 08-03-2007, 01:37 PM

So from reading DH we see how Kreacher's behavior changes towards Harry when he shows him a bit of respect and compassion. If Sirius would have shown Kreacher respect and kindness do you guys think Sirius' life would have been different?

Would Kreacher still have betrayed Sirius and the Order? And would he have lied to Harry about Sirius not being at Grimmauld Place (OotP)? And most importantly would Sirius still be alive? I know that may be a little far fetched but even minor details can have a big impact on what happens in life.

*Wasn't sure what Topic number we were on but I assumed it was 15...if that is incorrect please inform me and I will change the number. ^.^

08-03-2007, 01:37 PM	#1 (permalink)
BrightestWitch JõRJõR Sirius Pressie Queen Hermidana Thestral Location: St James Gate Join Date: Mar 2006 Posts: 35,036 Hogwarts RPG Name: Jaxx Bisera Fourth Year	SBFC Topic #16: Kreacher & Sirius' Relationship post-DH discussion So from reading DH we see how Kreacher's behavior changes towards Harry when he shows him a bit of respect and compassion. If Sirius would have shown Kreacher respect and kindness do you guys think Sirius' life would have been different? Would Kreacher still have betrayed Sirius and the Order? And would he have lied to Harry about Sirius not being at Grimmauld Place (OotP)? And most importantly would Sirius still be alive? I know that may be a little far fetched but even minor details can have a big impact on what happens in life. *Wasn't sure what Topic number we were on but I assumed it was 15...if that is incorrect please inform me and I will change the number. ^.^