SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

Ginny_Fan · 07-25-2007, 07:35 PM

Ok , the movie in itself was pretty good but i think its does the book a dis service. I mean how much did they miss out ?!? it was like the first parts of the movie were just quickly wizzing through the first however hundered pages of the book. It went from Harry been attacked by dementors , next thing you no hes on trail then within 20 mins Mr Weasley is been attack by Nagini ( which wasnt nearlly covered enough). Now i no thers people who will say things like well thers only so long you can make a movie but if the Lord Of The Rings films can be 3 hours or however long they are then why cant the HP movies be that long ?

Also what was up with the Snapes worst memory bit, No quidditch which meant no weasley is our king , no Ron and Hermoine becoming prefects and then at the end were in the book Harry smashed up Dumbledores office where was that ! it was just a quick convosation between them in the film! ... to someone who hasnt read the book then its a very good film but to us the pottermaniacs who have read the book however many times ive gotta say its dissapointing. anybody else share my views ?

07-25-2007, 07:35 PM	#1 (permalink)
Ginny_Fan Faerie Join Date: Jun 2007 Location: Llandudno (GMT) Posts: 4,208 Hogwarts RPG Name: Zander Diamond Fifth Year	A bit of a let down.... Ok , the movie in itself was pretty good but i think its does the book a dis service. I mean how much did they miss out ?!? it was like the first parts of the movie were just quickly wizzing through the first however hundered pages of the book. It went from Harry been attacked by dementors , next thing you no hes on trail then within 20 mins Mr Weasley is been attack by Nagini ( which wasnt nearlly covered enough). Now i no thers people who will say things like well thers only so long you can make a movie but if the Lord Of The Rings films can be 3 hours or however long they are then why cant the HP movies be that long ? Also what was up with the Snapes worst memory bit, No quidditch which meant no weasley is our king , no Ron and Hermoine becoming prefects and then at the end were in the book Harry smashed up Dumbledores office where was that ! it was just a quick convosation between them in the film! ... to someone who hasnt read the book then its a very good film but to us the pottermaniacs who have read the book however many times ive gotta say its dissapointing. anybody else share my views ? Last edited by Ginny_Fan; 07-25-2007 at 07:37 PM.