SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post

McFeisty · 07-23-2007, 07:08 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by r+h4ever1

Yes, Harry was so right to yell. I HATED how Lupin wanted to go with them. It would have been nice had he just wanted to go to protect or whatever, but I hated his attitude.

It's one thing for him to be concerned for the unborn Teddy's benefit. Yes, his life would be hard if he turned out to be a werewolf. But saying that he REGRETTED MARRYING TONKS?! I was appauled. It was so selfish and so unfair of him to say that. I'm totally glad that Harry yelled at him because he was 100% right in doing it.

Shannon

I personally don't know if I agree with you on the whole with this Shannon. I believe Harry doing this was the right thing as well, but I believe that Lupin offering help wasn't selfish he was trying to procure that they stayed alive for one and he also didn't want to hurt Tonks that didn't to me show Cowardace and Selfishness giving up something you love in Lupins case Tonks and the Baby was something he was willing to do to make sure they had a safe werewolf-free life.

Lupin at first loved Tonks and you knew this but he didn't want to marry her or show this love to anyone at all because he didn't want to hurt Tonks or give her a life that she did not deserve he loved her alot but leaving her was not the right idea. Staying with her was. He loved her and Ted and you knew this after he had stayed, Harry had struck and chord which made him believe that if he perished while fighting Voldemort and his 'army' he would atleast have a selfless loving godfather to leave his only son too. He knew that Harry would do the right thing and Harry saying what he said was the right thing at the time.

07-23-2007, 07:08 PM	#11 (permalink)
McFeisty Evanna's Promotions Banshee Join Date: Dec 2002 Location: Dancing In the RAIN Posts: 16,608 Hogwarts RPG Name: Amelia Johanson First Year Ministry RPG Name: Kyleigh "Kyle" Elizabeth Manning Minister's Office	♡ ♡ ♡ An Unnecessary Obsession ♡ ♡ ♡ Quote: Originally Posted by r+h4ever1 Yes, Harry was so right to yell. I HATED how Lupin wanted to go with them. It would have been nice had he just wanted to go to protect or whatever, but I hated his attitude. It's one thing for him to be concerned for the unborn Teddy's benefit. Yes, his life would be hard if he turned out to be a werewolf. But saying that he REGRETTED MARRYING TONKS?! I was appauled. It was so selfish and so unfair of him to say that. I'm totally glad that Harry yelled at him because he was 100% right in doing it. Shannon I personally don't know if I agree with you on the whole with this Shannon. I believe Harry doing this was the right thing as well, but I believe that Lupin offering help wasn't selfish he was trying to procure that they stayed alive for one and he also didn't want to hurt Tonks that didn't to me show Cowardace and Selfishness giving up something you love in Lupins case Tonks and the Baby was something he was willing to do to make sure they had a safe werewolf-free life. Lupin at first loved Tonks and you knew this but he didn't want to marry her or show this love to anyone at all because he didn't want to hurt Tonks or give her a life that she did not deserve he loved her alot but leaving her was not the right idea. Staying with her was. He loved her and Ted and you knew this after he had stayed, Harry had struck and chord which made him believe that if he perished while fighting Voldemort and his 'army' he would atleast have a selfless loving godfather to leave his only son too. He knew that Harry would do the right thing and Harry saying what he said was the right thing at the time. __________________