SnitchSeeker.com - View Single Post - SnitchSeeker Order of the Phoenix review #2 (spoilers only if you choose them)

Pigwidgeon Took · 07-13-2007, 03:57 AM

Great job!! Cool, pic and scan of watertower and pass... haha nice.

I agree, the dementors were really cool!!! Altho I felt the alleyway was the weirdest one I'd ever seen...

I didn't hear the Snape comment... I need to watch the movie again

Yes I agree, Sirius' death scene was not very good at all.

SPOILER!!: Because...

The Lupin/Harry scene just after this made me laugh, because of who I was watching the movie with. She's horrible like that.

Grawp WAS necessary to the story line: because if he wasn't there, then you wouldn't understand what Harry and Hermione were leading Umbridge too when the centaur scene started.

The kiss, umm.. yeah, mistletoe coming from nowhere... the feeling that they both really liked each other wasn't really there. I thought the kiss was weird

SPOILER!!: considering

That whole thing just made me think it was too weird.

The possession scene was funny with who I was sitting with. My friend Emma looked over and whispered, "Harry's really good at writhing" and I couldn't stop laughing. That made others in the theater turn around and look at me like I was a freak... haha.

Loved: Sirius punching Lucius, those kitten plates creeped me out too... haha yeah, the textboks...

I didn't notice the CherriOwls tho...

haha. And Hermione's "Just because you have the emotional range of a teaspoon," comment to Ron.

I also didn't like: Mrs. Figg, she didn't act at all like she should have in the book, no portrait of Sirius' mommy, yes the Marauders penseive scene was far too quick as well. It's like the spell they were best at was Stupefy, which doesn't do a whole lot of good against Death Eaters. and I HATED how they left out everything Quidditch yet again.

Yes, the ending was... not very good, really, and I was looking forward to Harry trashing Dubmbledore's office, he didn't even seem sad about Sirius, either. Not really.

The 3 scenes I had most been looking forward to:
Sirius' death scene.
Umbridge getting carried off by Centaurs.
Twins' escape.

The 3 scenes I was most disappointed in:
Sirius' death scene.
The ending in Dumbledore's office.
The Marauders' scene.

07-13-2007, 03:57 AM	#42 (permalink)
Pigwidgeon Took Micky Gee! Magical Reader Jam Pony Rider Nundu Location: Wangdoodleland. Join Date: Dec 2005 Posts: 26,577 Ministry RPG Name: Aricca Jade "AJ" Silverstone Magical Creatures	Great job!! Cool, pic and scan of watertower and pass... haha nice. I agree, the dementors were really cool!!! Altho I felt the alleyway was the weirdest one I'd ever seen... I didn't hear the Snape comment... I need to watch the movie again Yes I agree, Sirius' death scene was not very good at all. SPOILER!!: Because... The curtain did not exist, the "veil" was more like a mass of moving blob, and he just sort of became one with the wall and faded away, NOT a proper death for Sirius. If, indeed, he was killed by the Avada Kedavra curse as you are told in the movie, then why did he not react to it as Cedric had? Cedric flew back and landed surprised, Sirius stood there, and just fell backwards slowly, disappearing out of sight. The Lupin/Harry scene just after this made me laugh, because of who I was watching the movie with. She's horrible like that. Grawp WAS necessary to the story line: because if he wasn't there, then you wouldn't understand what Harry and Hermione were leading Umbridge too when the centaur scene started. The kiss, umm.. yeah, mistletoe coming from nowhere... the feeling that they both really liked each other wasn't really there. I thought the kiss was weird SPOILER!!: considering that moments before they had been talking about Cedric's death, that "Cedric was good, but... Voldemort was better" and then they kiss, with a moving picture of Cho's dead-ex-boyfriend behind them. That whole thing just made me think it was too weird. The possession scene was funny with who I was sitting with. My friend Emma looked over and whispered, "Harry's really good at writhing" and I couldn't stop laughing. That made others in the theater turn around and look at me like I was a freak... haha. Loved: Sirius punching Lucius, those kitten plates creeped me out too... haha yeah, the textboks... I didn't notice the CherriOwls tho... haha. And Hermione's "Just because you have the emotional range of a teaspoon," comment to Ron. I also didn't like: Mrs. Figg, she didn't act at all like she should have in the book, no portrait of Sirius' mommy, yes the Marauders penseive scene was far too quick as well. It's like the spell they were best at was Stupefy, which doesn't do a whole lot of good against Death Eaters. and I HATED how they left out everything Quidditch yet again. Yes, the ending was... not very good, really, and I was looking forward to Harry trashing Dubmbledore's office, he didn't even seem sad about Sirius, either. Not really. The 3 scenes I had most been looking forward to: Sirius' death scene. Umbridge getting carried off by Centaurs. Twins' escape. The 3 scenes I was most disappointed in: Sirius' death scene. The ending in Dumbledore's office. The Marauders' scene. Last edited by Pigwidgeon Took : 07-13-2007 at 04:02 AM.