Well where can i start first of all i loved the book.... the death i was not at all ready for and all that time i was thinking that it was going to be hagrid Guess i was wrong...When i did get to the death i was crying he was my favorite Person in the book besides the headmaster....i was really happy about the frist part of the book...i could not belive that there was stuff happing like 3 pages in the book...Some of the book though did kinda let me down..well with the "hooking up" we heard so much about there was not that much but harry getting with cho wicth was really good but that did not last long... and the end it seemed kinda rushed like she was just wanting to end the book but over all it was on of the best but i still like Poa better but OOTP comes in a close 2nd and 3rd GOF 4th COS and last but not least SS