The problem with such theories is: You NEVER know if they are right or wrong until the next book is out. At HP it doesn´t matter if something is possible or not. Or imaginary or not. NOTHING is imaginary at HP.
So even when this theory of snape being fawkes, seems to be very far fetched first. You never know what JKR is up to.
Finally. I´m happy about people like you who look beside the ways and thuink further.
|